MILTON – A newly-constructed elementary school and middle school were mostly off the table Tuesday during a public forum hosted by the Milton School Board.
Chair Kumulia Long said that while building a new school would be ideal to him, “stabilization” of the current building was the focus of the meeting, held in the high school library.
The Herrick building, constructed in phases beginning in 1954, is one of the oldest school facilities in Vermont, with parts of the building reaching the end of their expected life span.
An evaluation from architecture firm TruexCullins estimated the current K-8 grade building has about nine years of life left before it is deemed completely unsafe for students to attend classes in, with the current roof listed as a priority. The facility has faced ongoing issues, including mold, outdated infrastructure and a layout that no longer meets the needs of a modern educational environment.
After proposing a design for a new school in spring 2023, the district ultimately put the Herrick Avenue Project on hold due to cost concerns. The decision took into account a challenging budget season, when Milton residents ultimately approved the Milton Town School District 2025 budget on the third revision.
By making repairs to the schools, the buildings could ideally be habitable for longer, Long said, without the community having to experience the tax increases of building a new school.
“So the question is, where does the community want us to move?” Long said. “What direction would the community like to see us in?”
The potential plans for what to do with the schools were presented to about a dozen people, with most attending in-person and a few watching through Zoom.
The school board presented two courses of action via slideshow. First was “Course of Action 1,” focused on stabilization through repairs to the building. “Course of Action 2” is to build a new school.
The board focused on “Course of Action 1” and broke it down into two options. Option A includes fixing the elementary and middle school roofs and is projected to cost between $3-5 million. Other repairs in this option include sprinkler system repairs and updates to gutters and exterior drainage to help with water management.
Option B would include the repairs in Option A and add a few more for a total cost of $7-10 million. These repairs include new electrical distribution panels that are currently at the end of their lifespan, a new water heater and new windows.
At the end of the meeting, the board asked each community member to indicate which plan they would be in favor of, with all saying option B and some saying option B+ indicating they would also be in favor of building a new school in the present or future.
Members of the community shared questions and concerns with the board before sharing which option they thought best.
One community member in the library asked why the school board hadn’t been addressing these concerns all along.
“We don’t want to invest a lot of money into repairs when we heard from the public that they wanted a new building,” Long said. “We're not going to replace boilers, we're not going to do all of these things. If we're getting a new building, we're going to hold off.”
The same community member expressed concerns about the cost of the projects and asked why the school district’s capital reserve fund could not cover some of the cost.
Vice Chair Karen Stout said the capital fund is designed for emergencies.
“If something happens, like if the kindergarten wing floods, then we have to take out a loan, so then we're wasting more taxpayer dollars,” she said. “You can't deplete a fund to put bigger Band Aids on a problem.”
Melinda Young, a community member tuning in on Zoom, said it is important for the board to reach out to people who might not be directly involved with the schools in their day-to-day lives.
“Not everybody gets this information because they don't have children or family members who work in the school, so finding other ways of getting that information out there would be ideal for community input,” she said.
The Milton School Board plans to continue holding public forums to discuss the future of the elementary and middle school, Long said. Representatives of the board will also be at the craft fair on Nov. 9 at Milton High School.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here