Your Vote, Their Vision: Metcalf, Vadnais outline priorities in Milton School Board 3-year race

Posted

MILTON — As Town Meeting Day approaches, the Milton Independent is publishing a series called “Your Vote, Their Vision,” featuring candidate Q&As to help voters learn more about those seeking to serve the community. Each candidate was asked the same set of questions about local priorities, leadership and their vision for Milton’s future.

Today’s installment focuses on the race for a three-year seat on the Milton Town School District Board of Trustees.

Incumbent Jeremy Metcalf, who has lived in Milton since 1999 and currently serves as vice chair of the board, is seeking re-election. Metcalf said he is most proud of helping to put the district in a stronger position, citing stable leadership, strengthened reserve funds and long-term planning for facilities as key areas of progress. He also emphasized preparing the district for potential statewide education changes as a major focus moving forward.

He is challenged by Cathy Vadnais, a retired educator, former Milton School Board member (2014-2018) and current Milton Library Trustee, who is seeking a return to the board. Vadnais pointed to her background in education, governance and finance — including experience in budgeting, curriculum and oversight — as preparation for the role.

Both candidates identified differing priorities in their responses. Metcalf emphasized preparing Milton for the implementation of Act 73, protecting reserve funds for local students and taxpayers, and balancing budgets while minimizing impacts on students. Vadnais highlighted academics, accountability and affordability, with a focus on strengthening literacy and math instruction, maintaining fiscal responsibility and ensuring effective district oversight.

Editor's note: Candidate responses appear largely in their own words and were edited only for clarity, spelling and length. The Milton Independent asked each candidate the same questions to ensure fairness.

Q&A

Why are you running for the Milton Town School District Board, and what motivates you to serve students and families? 

Jeremy Metcalf: “I originally ran for office because I was disgusted and concerned with the many missteps of the board and administration in 2017. I have stayed on the board because I care about Milton’s schools and want to build on the progress we’ve made. I also want to help Milton transition to the new state vision that is coming.”

Cathy Vadnais: “I am retired and have the time and energy to fully commit to this role. As a parent of post-high school students, I understand the importance of preparing students for life beyond graduation. I believe my experiences and perspective can help guide the district through the significant changes facing education today.”

The state has proposed Act 73 in an effort to balance educational quality with rising costs. Do you agree with the plan?

Metcalf: “The current system is broken.  It is a patchwork of many layers of fixes that have been applied over the years, each of them intended to fix a problem but coming with unintended consequences.  I think the idea of larger districts that are better able to pool resources and operate larger schools has merit, both to decrease costs and to improve student outcomes.  While there are potential downsides to combining or consolidating, there also may be benefits to our families.  I look forward to seeing what the legislature develops as this year’s session moves forward.” 

Vadnais: “My understanding is that Act 73 was introduced in response to the unsustainable cost of education. While it aims to curb expenses and provide relief to taxpayers, I have reservations. I recognize the need for a bold, new approach, but we must carefully consider the potential trade-offs. Since it is now law, I believe it is important to review the final implementation details before drawing conclusions.”

How do you approach decision-making when opinions among parents, staff and community members differ? 

Metcalf: “It can be very difficult, especially around budget time.  As a board member, I have an obligation not only to provide a high-quality education to students but also to provide it in a fiscally responsible way.  I try to make sure I understand the viewpoint of each stakeholder group and if possible, try to make a balanced decision.”

Vadnais: “I approach decision-making thoughtfully and rely on facts, data and what best serves the community as a whole. I believe it is important to listen carefully because people want to be heard and their concerns acknowledged. When opinions differ, I remain open to reasonable compromise. However, my final decision will always prioritize what is in the best interest of all students.”

Some Milton families have raised questions about LGBTQ+ inclusion and student support. What is your perspective on creating an inclusive environment for all students?

Metcalf: “It’s vital that ALL students feel safe and able to learn in school.  Building a community where all students feel included and comfortable to be themselves will put them in a position to achieve at their highest.  Providing resources for training to faculty and staff on how to create an inclusive community, ensuring policies and procedures are in place, and that they are followed is the role of the board.  Another role of the board is to lead by example and embody the values of being inclusive and supportive to our students and families.” 

Vadnais: “Schools have a responsibility to provide safe classrooms and strong academics that prepare every student for adult life. All students deserve to feel safe, respected and supported. While LGBTQ students may face unique challenges, they are not the only students who can feel isolated or unseen. We must be attentive to the mental health and well-being of all students. My family has experienced the tragic loss of a loved one to suicide, and that experience reinforced for me the importance of ensuring students know there are adults ready to listen and help. I support efforts that foster belonging, resilience and open communication so that every student feels valued and supported in our schools.”

What does Milton’s school community mean to you personally?

Metcalf: “It means joy.  When I walk around the schools, or see students at a board meeting, or competing in athletics, or performing in a play, I love seeing the joy on their faces.  School and learning should be an exercise in joy.  When my children come home and tell me about what they did that day and I see the joy and excitement, it makes my day.  When I see our wonderful faculty and staff interact with students and encouraging that joy of learning, it makes me proud to be a part of the school district.  With all of the negativity that permeates so much of the election season, it’s good to remember what we’re here for: the children. I want to have a school that students want to come to and are happy to learn and become their best selves.” 

Vadnais: “Education is the cornerstone of our community and society. As a parent of three Milton graduates, I’ve seen firsthand how strong schools can shape a student’s future. Life is not a dress rehearsal, and it is our responsibility to provide a high-quality education that equips the next generation to thrive, contribute and succeed in all aspects of life.”

Why should voters support your candidacy?

Metcalf: “In my time on the board, we have made progress almost every year.  We have a stable administration, we’ve built up reserve funds for unexpected future needs in both facilities and education, and we have a solid plan to stabilize the Herrick Avenue school with the recently passed bond.  I will continue looking out for our schools as Act 73 comes to fruition, doing my best to ensure the best outcome for Milton.”

Vadnais: “Please support my candidacy for the three-year Milton School Board seat. I bring experience, independence and proven results. Previously, I helped establish the capital reserve fund, controlled budget growth, improved school facilities and protected taxpayers from unnecessary costs. I ask for your trust and support to continue keeping Milton schools strong, accountable and focused on student success.” 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here