
This commentary is by Matt Wormser, the chair of the Shelburne Selectboard.
I traveled to Fayetteville, Arkansas, earlier this year for work. Having not been to the state in decades, I didn’t know what to expect, but anticipated an environment similar to many Southern cities I’d been to in recent years: long on MAGA and sprawl and short on local color. Instead, I found a colorful small city that reminded me of Burlington. It’s home to the vibrant University of Arkansas campus. The tourism welcome center sold “Keep Fayetteville Funky” shirts. Pride flags abounded, as did a variety of great restaurants, coffee shops, small parks and well-maintained older homes. I spent a couple of days biking around town, and it seemed like a great place to live.
One striking difference in my meanderings was that there was no evidence — zero — of public drug use or addiction.
I’ll contrast that with my recent bike ride into my downtown Burlington office this week, where, passing City Hall Park, I saw a nice new pickup doing a tidy business with a long line of customers obviously stuck in the abyss of addiction. Walking to lunch revealed plenty more of the same. While Vermont has made progress on opiate deaths, looking at 2024 data from the Kaiser Family Foundation, it still has the fifth-worst opiate-related death rate in the country at 29 per 100,000 people. By contrast, Arkansas, a state with a significantly higher poverty rate than Vermont, offering far fewer public health and housing assistance resources, saw the fourth-lowest rate nationally, at 6.2 per 100,000. In short, Vermonters die of opiates at nearly five times the rate of Arkansans. Nationally, seven of the 10 states with the highest rates of opiate-related deaths are so-called blue states, while nine of the 10 states with the lowest rates are “red” ones. It’s hard to avoid the conclusion that whatever we’re doing in blue states to combat drug abuse, it isn’t working.
What’s different? While multiple factors drive addiction, states like Vermont in recent years have embraced the strategy of harm reduction, with the goal of minimizing addiction-related deaths. Most days, to many Vermonters, this simply feels like an abandonment of drug law enforcement, with the hope that users will summon the agency to seek treatment and then stay sober. What is evident from the data is that this de facto policy is killing Vermonters at a far higher rate than necessary and impacting the quality of life for everyone else. From a visibility standpoint, Burlington is the poster child for public drug use and addiction, but this is by no means simply a “crazy Burlington progs” issue, as the per capita death rate from opiates is not notably higher in Chittenden County versus other Vermont counties.
The issue can also be attributed to the highly decentralized nature of our policing in Vermont, where small local departments with limited resources by necessity spend far more time responding to the byproducts of trafficking and addiction — shoplifting, car break-ins, disorderly conduct, no-trespass orders — than addressing the root cause itself.
Few families have been unaffected by the opiate crisis over the past decade; mine is certainly not on the exception list. Families supporting their loved ones struggling with addiction know that there is a fine line between support and enablement, and statewide we’ve dipped far too strongly into the latter category. Advocates of harm reduction say the policy is working and we only need time, ever more time. To me, the numbers tell the exact opposite story. While some leaders decry the whack-a-mole nature of scooping up low-level dealers, I think most Vermonters would enthusiastically welcome more incarceration of dealers of all stripes in preference to the current policy in Burlington and beyond.
We need Vermont’s leaders to work far more actively, and in a far more coordinated way, on enforcement of laws for our most life-destroying drugs: opiates and methamphetamines. This includes aggressive targeting of dealer networks from low to high, while holding out a hand for addicts seeking treatment. It also includes addressing some of the known issues enabling trafficking in Vermont, such as the drugs-for-guns trade resulting from our very laissez-faire gun laws.
Well over 1,000 Vermonters have died due to opiates since Covid-19. Our current enforcement policy is a choice, resulting in tremendous costs to affected individuals, families and communities. Many other blue states have successfully changed course in their tolerance and policies for drug distribution and public use, without losing their humanity in treating addiction. We need leaders from all our parties to do likewise.
Read the story on VTDigger here: Vermont’s opiate policy is killing us.
Courtesy of VT Digger