Vermont education transformation gets underway: CESAs form, merger committees are on the horizon

Posted

NORTHWEST VERMONT — With all the steadiness of a newborn, education transformation in Vermont is underway. 

The Champlain Valley North Cooperative Education Service Area met for the first time Aug. 3 to begin discussions about shared services. But the six superintendents in the room had many more questions than answers. 

“One of the things we have to think about as a group is, how much are we in favor of this taking off and having legs?” Bill Kimball, superintendent of Maple Run Unified School District, said. 

In 2025, Gov. Phil Scott challenged lawmakers to reimagine Vermont’s education system to better support students and reduce costs for taxpayers. The result was Act 73, which established a process for transitioning to larger school districts, a weighted student funding formula and a statewide tax rate.

This past legislative session, lawmakers extended the timeline via Act 170, pivoted from state-directed redistricting to district-led mergers, and mandated participation in cooperative educational service areas or CESAs. 

The Champlain Valley North CESA is made up of Maple Run Unified School District, Franklin West Supervisory Union, Milton Town School District, Grand Isle Supervisory Union, Missisquoi Valley School District and Franklin Northeast Supervisory Union. 

Sharing vs. merging 

There are seven CESAs across the state, each tasked with providing shared programs and services to their member districts. By sharing services, districts could potentially avoid duplication, equalize access and reduce costs. 

Back in April, Jill Graham, executive director of the Vermont Learning Collaborative, told the Senate Education Committee that CESAs have been in existence since the early 1900s. 

“They were created in response to real, persistent challenges facing local school districts that did not have the scale or the resources to provide specialized services,” she said. “This helps schools…especially smaller or more rural ones.” 

In 2024, for example, Ohio’s 51 service centers saved local schools almost $100 million, as compared to the cost of purchasing or developing services themselves. 

Today, CESAs exist in some shape or form in most of the 50 U.S. states. 

But over the last two years, districts across Vermont have expressed skepticism of the model, arguing CESAs create another level of bureaucracy that could add further confusion to an already complex system. 

Vermont Secretary of Education Zoie Saunders told lawmakers this past spring she also is not supportive of the approach. The Scott administration still prefers mandatory district mergers. 

But that idea also failed to gain broad momentum, leading lawmakers to suggest, rather than require, 20 school district re-groupings. At the same time CESAs are forming, merger committees will begin meeting this October, with possible mergers being voted on in March 2028. 

Setting up a CESA

All six local superintendents make up the Champlain Valley North CESA board of directors, and they voted MVSD Superintendent Julie Regimbal chair of the board Aug. 3. Kimball will serve as treasurer and FWSU Superintendent John Tague as clerk. 

To start, the group is tasked with writing bylaws and creating a public website. The Vermont Agency of Education is providing CESAs with $15,000 in start-up funds, which could pay a lawyer to review bylaws and fund any website needs. 

Next, the CESA will need to review its assets. What services already exist in its districts, and could they be pooled or expanded? What doesn’t exist that needs to be created? 

According to the Agency of Education, shared services should include special education, transportation and information technology, among others. 

“We are not looking to put in services that everybody’s got in their buildings,” Regimbal said. “We’re looking to put in missing services that people are struggling to find.” 

“Or combining to do more efficiently,” Kimball added. 

As an example, instead of each district negotiating its own contract with a bus company, the CESA could enter into a single contract for all members. 

Beyond the $15,000 in start-up money, CESAs will be funded by membership fees paid by each school district based on student enrollment. Utilizing a CESA service will also cost a fee; price to be determined. 

Superintendents questioned how taxpayers would react to that additional spend — especially without a concrete return on investment. 

“If we have to go to our community for money, many of them have a hard enough time understanding how our budgets work as it is,” Milton Town School District Superintendent Amy Rex said. “If we are going to be asking for money initially, without any idea of return … that could be very challenging.” 

All of the superintendents agreed any shared service will take some time to get up and running, so they could be asking taxpayers to contribute without an immediate result. 

“If we are spending a lot of money on the CESA without savings, our communities are going to struggle with passing budgets, as many of us already do,” Regimbal said. 

Per state law, CESAs need to hire an executive director to manage the day-to-day operations of shared services. Many districts already have staff in their central offices who oversee things like IT and transportation, so moving those tasks to the CESA could create some savings via eliminated positions. 

The Vermont Agency of Education is supplying CESAs with a $50,000 salary for the executive director role, but local superintendents doubted someone would do the job for that compensation. 

“I think we’d be hard-pressed to find someone to be the executive director of an entity like this for $50,000,” Franklin Northeast Superintendent Lynn Cota said. 

As the CESA gets up and running, the role could be a part-time position. CESA membership fees could also go toward increasing the ED’s salary. 

“I’d love it if someone fell from the sky,” Regimbal said. 

The Champlain Valley North CESA board will next meet Thursday, Sept. 3 in Swanton. The group plans to meet monthly to start, although the law only requires four meetings per year. 

Superintendents said they will provide updates to their local school boards after each meeting. 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here