VERMONT — From the Vermont State House to the dining room table, talk of a housing crisis and economic uncertainty often has had a daunting, perhaps unwelcome, seat at the table.
Broaching such conversations can sometimes feel overwhelming — but the implications of such challenges have the potential to lurk and grow each day they are ignored.
The Vermont Futures Project, a non-partisan, data-driving think tank, proposes increasing the state’s population is key to solving our problems. Bringing Vermont's population up to 802,000 total people by 2035 could lower taxes, fuel the economy and bring down healthcare costs.
As the clock ticks, the Futures Project is moving the conversation forward in a productive manner and empowering residents and legislators alike to find solutions for a brighter future.
Feeling disoriented in the face of looming challenges? Keep reading to start finding your footing.
The Vermont Futures Project’s primary function is to research and compile data around what the state needs to do now to ensure an economically and socially sustainable, viable future, as well as to communicate Vermont’s other possible futures and the steps to get there to the public.
From there, it is up to voters, legislators and developers to decide which future they want.
The Vermont Futures Project emerged from the Vermont Chamber of Commerce in 2015, as an entity separate from the policy work of that chamber, and with its own 501(c)(3) status. The Vermont Futures Project is housed in the parent organization, Vermont Chamber Foundation.
“They advocate on behalf of the business community to create conditions for economic vitality,” the project’s executive director, Kevin Chu, told the Sun — referring to the Chamber of Commerce itself.
“They noticed a lot of policy gets shaped by the loudest voice in the room, the opinion of the moment, whatever's trending on social media, for better or worse,” he added. “They launched the Futures Project to bring a consistent data and research perspective to these big issues.”
The issues being: An aging population, housing and worker availability for and among working-aged Vermonters, general affordability for this new generation and a plethora of other interrelated difficulties that are cyclically contributing to the severity of one another.
Chu joined the Vermont Futures Project in January of 2022, because he believes in a fruitful future for his home state. He grew up in Vermont and he looks forward to growing old in Vermont, too. The son of immigrants, his parents didn’t have college degrees or speak English.
“My parents came to Vermont, of all places, back in 1986 and they had one social connection at the time. I have an aunt who married an American, and they happen to live in Vermont, so that's how my family ended up here,” Chu said. “They came here for the hope of pursuing the American Dream, for economic opportunity. I'm lucky to say they were able to find it here.”
His parents found success by forming a community of people who wanted to see them succeed and were able to raise their three boys and ultimately put them through college, Chu said. His mom spent most of her career working as a janitor, where she met lots of other New Americans, and began taking English classes for free through the University of Vermont, her employer.
“I am inspired by their story and what they were willing to sacrifice to make it work,” Chu said. “And I want to make sure that opportunity continues to be part of the Vermont narrative, not only today, but moving forward into the future too. That's what inspires me.”
Chu believes the Vermont Futures Project has carved out a unique niche within the economic development ecosystem, of serving as a translation service of sorts, to help take complex ideas and distill them into an easy to understand framework that can accurately and effectively educate the public.
In this way, when people — whether it be at the state level, local level or anywhere in between — are trying to have these hard discussions and make tough decisions that will have a ripple effect once put into action, decision-makers can pick direction with the best information possible in mind.
One goal the Futures Project launched last year was to grow Vermont’s population to 802,000 by 2035, alongside a development goal of increasing the number of non-seasonal homes to about 350,000 total, to ensure a physical capacity practical for a population of that size.
These numbers as goals were informed by a workforce gap analysis, looking at workforce supply and demand, with consideration to how many high school graduates Vermont produces each year, how many college graduates the state retains, inward-and-outward migration, and retirement and other workforce exits.
A decade ago, there were two job-seekers for every single open job — more people looking than work available. Today, that’s pretty much an inverted ratio. If every person looking for work in Vermont found a Vermont-based job, there would still be about 10,000 remaining open jobs.
“It's very much imbalanced,” Chu said. “There's far more demand than supply. So on an annual basis, we found that Vermont should be trying to add about 13,500 people into the workforce each year.”
“Some of that can be filled with people who are already here,” he added. “But given how skewed the demographic distribution of our state is, we also need to take a look at bringing more people here as a possible solution to fill that gap.”
“It's a situation where we either have to grow the population, especially the working age population — because when we say workforce, we really mean people,” Chu said. “Or the other possible scenario is job opportunities start to go away.”
Vermonters do have options. “Futures” is plural — so there are multiple pathways.
“If the population doesn’t grow, businesses start to close because they can't find the workers that they need, or they leave the state altogether, and then it creates this vicious cycle of decline where opportunity begins to fade from the Vermont narrative,” Chu said.
Some of the other most pressing issues are the rising costs of healthcare, as well as the taxpayer burden being carried by a small enough population that each individual feels it heavily.
“The dangers of doing nothing are known,” Chu said. “That's where data is really helpful. If we look at trends, trends tell us where we're going to go if the status quo holds, so we'd see declining state revenues and increased cost of living.”
Vermont has a property tax system that's income-sensitive. So as folks retire, often their income level goes down, which means they receive a homestead tax credit. But it doesn't mean the total revenue that needs to be raised goes down. It shifts the burden to working-age people.
That's what’s causing property tax increases in relation to healthcare. When folks retire, they're shifting to Medicare or Medicaid, and those reimbursement rates to the hospitals to provide care are often less than the actual cost of the service itself.
So, the shortfall needs to be made up by shifting the cost burden to commercial rate payers when insurance costs go up. These are some of the underlying demographic pressures going on. The goal to grow the population is meant to help the people who are here, afford to stay.
“It's to make sure we have an adequate workforce to provide for some of the basic services that everyone says they want, things like healthcare, child care and a solid education,” Chu said. “To make sure we have an adequate workforce to pursue some of our climate goals. It's sort of this lever, the workforce — the people who are here are the ones who get the work done.”
Prior to joining the Vermont Futures Project, Chu’s background was in environmental studies.
Having a broader tax base would allow the state to raise revenue to invest in climate-resilient infrastructure, he said. A larger population would also bring more hands to the ground for recovery efforts in the wake of any natural disaster the state might see moving forward.
“It also attends to this sort of global phenomena of migration induced by climate change,” Chu said. “Vermont needs more people. We can take a look at that through an economic lens, but from an environmental lens — more people need a Vermont.”
In other words, on a relative basis, Vermont is much less vulnerable to the impacts of climate change than many other regions around the country and certainly around the world.
It’s not that Vermont won't be impacted by climate change, but there are regions of the U.S. that are running out of water, where there's drought and wildfire, Chu said, as well as coastal cities home to millions who might not be on the map in 50 to 100 years, as oceans rise.
“So where are those people to go?” he said. “A lot of projections show the northeast of Vermont in particular being a relatively favorable place to relocate to. So if we know that, we should be proactive in creating enough capacity, building enough houses so that the relocation becomes a viable option, not just to the wealthy and the privileged.”
Vermont is already home to climate migrants who have made such moves, but Chu believes this option should also be a practical pathway for anyone from any background. If Vermont doesn't answer that call proactively, what will happen is displacement.
“Wealth wins when there's scarcity — everyone wins when there's abundance,” he added. “But we haven't really, honestly as a state, tried to pursue housing abundance with any sort of sincerity.”
Chu believes, if Vermont is to tip the scales in a more equitable direction — which would benefit the overall health of the state, including employers, in the long run — one of the primary mechanisms for doing so would be to shift the default answer on housing proposals to “yes.”
This includes providing education to combat the “not in my backyard” movement among current residents who are opposed to new development projects in their neighborhoods — better known as NIMBYism — as well as tweaking legislation to align development and land use laws more appropriately with the urgency of Vermont’s current reality.
The latter initiative would involve decreasing regulatory barriers that stifle lots of efforts at development, many of which came about as a possibly unintended consequence of Act 250.
“I see and hear the phrase all the time that we're in a housing crisis, and people say housing is a human right,” Chu said. “A crisis requires acting with urgency. If housing is a human right then it should be a right to build housing.”
“But now, whenever there's a housing proposal, sometimes it takes three to five years before all the permitting processes, legal processes play out before a shovel hits the ground,” he added.
With that said, the Vermont Futures Project does not lobby or push for specific legislation. Its role is to simply present information to decision-makers.
When asked if building more housing would be the number one best thing to prioritize at the start of a journey toward ensuring this prosperous imagined future can happen in Vermont, Chu said it would be a fair statement.
“We're also not breaking the laws of physics by trying to build more housing,” he said. “In many locations around the country, they’ve figured out how to accelerate housing construction, and the level of growth that we're proposing is actually a level that Vermont has seen in its past.”
This rapid growth took hold after the 1950s, continuing through the ‘80s, with the construction of interstate highways and the back-to-the-land movement. Vermont’s response was to implement Act 250, to manage the growth rate and mitigate the environmental impacts of development.
That was just before some of the primary federal environmental regulations came about to take on that protective role. But now it's 54 years later, and we can see the disconnect between the intent and the impact of Act 250, Chu said.
In addition to suppressing development, Act 250 might have encouraged sprawl, he said.
“There are Vermonters who say we don't have the carrying capacity for that many people, or Vermont's already beyond a sustainable population level,” he said. “This inherent aversion to growth, and sometimes it tries to weaponize the environmental perspective.”
The actual data on sustainability and on a per capita basis for greenhouse gas emissions shows Vermont is doing worse than states like New Jersey, Massachusetts and New York — but on account of sprawl, transportation emissions and a lack of economies of scale.
A quarter of Vermont’s homes were built before 1940 and hence are not thermally efficient.
From this perspective, a modernized, weatherized, denser, faster approach to housing build-outs would serve as a win-win for the environment and the economy, Chu said.
People have also raised questions about the practicality of hitting some of the ambitious growth-rate goals that experts say are necessary to a strong local economy in the future. But reframing doubts into realistic glimmers of hope is possible, given what we know now, Chu said.
“Part of what's pushing prices higher is demand with low supply,” he said. “But to me, that's actually a really good sign that people want to be here, that Vermont is desirable.”
This may have been influenced by the COVID-19 pandemic and other factors, but Vermont is in a much better position as a state where people want to be, rather than the opposite scenario, where everyone's leaving and there's no hope, Chu said.
Another critique Chu said he sometimes hears is people questioning the validity of his data.
“And I say, ‘It's not my data — it's our data,’” he said. “These numbers represent all of us, and I aggregate information from sources like the U.S. Census Bureau, the Bureau of Labor Statistics, the Bureau of Economic Analysis, the Vermont Department of Labor.”
“That's why I feel like the Futures Project is a translation service,” he added. “All of this information is publicly available, just sort of hard to access and interpret. So if someone's questioning the validity of the data, they're also questioning the validity of the Census Bureau.”
Another frequently-asked question: What if we do nothing?
“A really good starting point for doing nothing is by not talking about it,” Chu said. “Problem avoidance. And time only works in one direction. So with some of these demographic pressures, we're not going to be able to reverse aging. We're not going to be able to turn back the clock.”
Since we know what the impacts could be, Chu recommends engaging in productive, open-minded dialogue to discuss potential solutions.
“One way of thinking is in terms of right or wrong,” Chu said. “But it's more about figuring out what that future of Vermont should and could look like, and those are very values-driven conversations. What I try to do is paint a picture of what's possible.”
In his presentations to the public, Chu likes to show a three-pronged Venn diagram of options to viewers so they can visualize possibilities and decide their positions based on a desired outcome within the confines of real-world limitations.
There are three circles: “I want stable services,” “I want low-density” and “I want low taxes” — and an option where all three happen does not exist — you can only choose two. Low density and low taxes would result in service cuts. Low density and stable services mean high taxes.
Giving up the desire for traditional, low density housing would make both low taxes and stable services a simultaneous option, and would serve to stabilize the local economy in the long run, according to the research.
What the Futures Project proposes with these goals is a more affordable Vermont that can also meet the current and future needs of its citizens. That's represented by the stable services part, meeting people's needs.
To do that, Chu’s team proposes increasing the population. That would increase density. That doesn't mean it's the only option for Vermont, or the right or wrong option, he said.
“It's trying to stitch together the possible solutions and highlight that this is complicated, and there isn't a silver bullet thing that's going to solve all of our issues, and we have to know the potential impact or return on investment and the decisions that we make,” he said.
“But we can't just train our way out of our workforce shortage, because what we end up doing is just shifting people from one industry to another and playing this big game of whack a mole,” he added. “We either need more people or those opportunities are going to go away. We have a situation where different industries and sectors are unintentionally and directly competing with each other.”
Sometimes looking at numbers at the statewide level can feel scary, he said, but with any major long-term goal, it’s important to take it up in smaller chunks and understand the different components and what they mean at the local, annual level.
The amount of growth needed to reach the 802,000 populaion goal in a decade would be about 2% growth per year, and distributing that growth by section of the state.Going down to the county and municipal level, it often feels even more achievable and reassuring.
“I think when people hear that, they're like, ‘Wait, 2% — it's doable,’” Chu said. “For example, I gave a presentation to the Shelburne selectboard last fall, and when it began, I noticed a sort of defensive posture in the room and a sense of skepticism.”
“But if we break it down proportionally, for what that means for Shelburne, it’s about 150 people per year and about 75 houses,” he said. “And the mood completely changed, because now people are like, ‘Oh, wait, that'd be really good for our community, there'd be more kids in our schools, there'd be more vibrancy at the local farmers market.’”
One Vermont Futures Project’s analyses looked at historical population peak versus current population, recognizing that many towns and villages in Vermont depopulated, and looked at what that means for the carrying capacity of many Vermont towns.
“A lot of the recent growth in Vermont has happened in and around Chittenden County,” Chu said. “But this to me is also really encouraging, because if we were just to work on rural repopulation, bringing many of these towns back to their historical peak, we’d have over 70,000 more people today. That gets us about halfway there.”
The fact that these towns used to be home to more people than they currently are also means a lot of the infrastructure to support those numbers may already be in place. If a town used to have 5,000 people and they have 2,500 now, they have capacity for growth, and may crave it.
Growth would also mean a lot for Vermont in terms of diversifying its population, and it’ll take a lot of growth not only to keep up a hardy state economy, but also to see real DEI improvements.
“I think that for all the statements made about diversity, equity and inclusion, and the desire for Vermont to be socially progressive, growth is a practical pathway to hold ourselves accountable,” Chu said. “If 155,000 people of color moved to Vermont, we'd still be 75% white.”
So — where to from here?
Only time will tell.
Those interested in seeing a more detailed breakdown of the numbers factoring into future projections, and reading more about Vermont’s possible futures, may do so on the Vermont Futures Project website.
The site’s “data dashboards” web pages analyze Vermont’s performance, trajectory and possibility, when it comes to demographics, racial diversity, economic activity, innovation and entrepreneurship, workforce and talent, quality of place, and infrastructure and investment.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here