MILTON — When Taramesha Tatro and her husband bought their four-bedroom home in Milton for $450,000 in 2022, they thought they were securing their future in Vermont.
Now, just two years later, they’re questioning whether they can afford to stay. She said their property taxes have nearly doubled, and their daughter and her financé — both working full-time — are leaving the state for Tennessee after struggling to find an apartment they can afford.
Tatro’s story is one of many similar in Vermont, where rising home prices, limited inventory and soaring rents have made it increasingly difficult for families, young professionals and retirees to find housing within their means.
As more longtime residents consider leaving, local officials and housing advocates are searching for solutions to a crisis that is reshaping communities across Chittenden County.
According to local realtors, home prices in Milton, and all across Vermont, have risen dramatically in recent years.
Data from the Vermont Housing Finance Agency shows the median home price in Chittenden County has surged by over 30% in the past five years. As of 2024, the median home price in Milton hovers around $400,000. For many middle-income families, that price point is out of reach.
A 2023 VHFA report estimated a household would need an annual income of at least $100,000 to comfortably afford a home at that price, assuming a standard mortgage and down payment. However, U.S. Census data shows that Milton’s median household income is significantly lower, making homeownership difficult for local residents.
The rental market is equally challenging, with statewide vacancy rates below 2%, according to a report from the Vermont Department of Housing and Community Development. With limited options, both renters and buyers find themselves competing in an increasingly unaffordable market.
Jordan LaFond, a realtor with Keller Williams Realty, said the current market differs significantly from the pandemic-era housing boom, when low interest rates made homes more accessible.
“Housing prices have gone up across the board,” LaFond said. “In Vermont, we have some things that limit the ability for us to develop enough housing for the demand. Act 250, for example, limits the amount any one developer can build within a certain area and timeframe.”
Act 250 is Vermont’s landmark land use law that regulates development and environmental impacts across the state.
The act has been cited as making it harder for developers to build new housing in high-demand areas. According to a report by the Vermont Housing and Conservation Board, the act contributes to Vermont having fewer than 6,000 new housing units built each year, while over 8,000 units are needed to meet the state’s current demand.
LaFond also said limited supply has pushed prices higher, with condos in Milton now selling for upwards of $400,000.
“I sold one of these new builds over on Greenbrook, and my client paid almost $500,000 for it,” she said.
The rise in home values has made it harder for first-time buyers to enter the market.
Many of LaFond’s clients, despite being pre-approved for higher amounts, are hesitant to purchase due to economic uncertainty.
“Buyers are definitely more skeptical,” she said. “Some people have friends losing their jobs, and they just don’t know what’s going to happen. With all of the uncertainty on a state and federal level right now, a lot of people are just holding off on buying or selling.”
“What we need across the state is more ‘affordable housing’” LaFond added.
Affordable Housing is generally defined as housing where the occupant is spending no more than 30% of their gross income on housing costs, including rent or mortgage payments, utilities and taxes. This threshold is a key measure used by government programs, such as the Department of Housing and Urban Development, to determine housing affordability.
In Vermont, this often means households making less than 80% of the area’s median income are more likely to struggle to find affordable housing without assistance or subsidies.To address this, state and federal programs offer financial incentives — such as grants, tax credits and low-interest loans — to developers who include designated affordable housing units in their projects.
These incentives can help offset construction costs, making it more feasible to build housing that meets affordability standards. However, demand for these units continues to outpace supply, leaving many residents with limited options.
In addition to high prices, financing challenges and strict zoning regulations have made homeownership increasingly difficult.
Many Vermont towns, including Milton, have zoning laws that limit high-density housing, require large lot sizes, or impose lengthy permitting requirements. These factors drive up costs and restrict new development. These regulations, originally intended to control growth and preserve community character, can make it harder to build smaller, more affordable homes or multi-family units that could ease the housing crunch.
Joe Diamond, a realtor with Vermont Real Estate Company, said there is a need for more flexible financing options, particularly for first-time buyers interested in fixer-uppers.
“If I had a magic wand, I would create an incentive program specifically for first-time home buyers,” Diamond said. “Something like a state or federal program that matches what they save for closing costs, encouraging people to build better saving habits.”
Diamond added that the construction industry plays a critical role in the affordability crisis.
“It’s expensive to build new construction, and the prices reflect that,” he said. “We also need competitive wages for construction workers to help address the housing shortage.”
Renters face similar struggles. The fair market rent for a two-bedroom apartment in Milton has climbed to nearly $1,600 per month, requiring a tenant to earn over $30 per hour to afford it without being cost-burdened. In Chittenden County alone, there is a documented shortage of nearly 3,000 affordable rental units, according to the Champlain Housing Trust. This shortage contributes to the low vacancy rate and skyrocketing rental prices in the area.
"We’re seeing more people spending well over 30% of their income on housing, which means less money for essentials like food, healthcare and transportation," Diamond said.
While the financial burden of housing is evident, the domino effect to other aspects of life might not be as understood.
Jennifer Saunders, the homeless liaison for the Milton Town School District, has seen firsthand how housing insecurity affects students and their families. Currently, the district assists 37 homeless students, though numbers have fluctuated between 30 and 50 in recent years.
"When I first started, we had numbers in the single digits," Saunders said. "Then COVID hit, and it exploded. At one point, we had 103 homeless students. It’s been a significant issue ever since."
Saunders said housing instability contributes to increased absenteeism, dropouts and behavioral issues in the classroom.
The district has reported a 40% rise in behavior referrals and a 60% increase in absenteeism among homeless students. In the 2023-2024 school year, average days missed for students experiencing homelessness was 27.9, versus 19.6 days for their housed peers.
"A child who has experienced homelessness at any point in their academic career has lower graduation rates, lower attendance and a decreased likelihood of pursuing post-secondary education," she said.
To support affected students, the district provides transportation, clothing and other essentials through grants and community partnerships. However, Saunders noted these efforts are only temporary solutions to a larger issue.
"Affordable housing is one of the biggest issues in Vermont, in Milton, probably across the country," she said. "People who, for whatever reason, do not have full-time work simply cannot afford to live and have to choose between shelter, a vehicle and food."
Saunders also raised concerns about the sustainability of assistance programs if federal funding declines.
"If federal funding dries up or is capped, then local communities will need to step up to support homeless students," she said. "That will impact school budgets and place a greater responsibility on communities to support their neighbors."
Certain groups within the population are particularly vulnerable if federal funding for programs like this are cut. Saunders mentioned LGBTQ+ students face heightened risk due to family rejection after coming out.
"The other concern that I have with our current administration is rights for the LGBTQ+ community, and the impact of that on young people who are coming out," Saunders said. "There are a lot of national statistics around the increase in homelessness and homelessness for people who have come out to their families, and to lose targeted support for those students...that could be tragic."
According to national statistics, nearly 40% of homeless youth identify as LGBTQ+, a stark contrast to the overall 4-5% of the general population who identify as such.
Saunders said it’s important to be empathetic and aware, as many people may not realize they already know someone struggling with housing insecurity.
"I can guarantee you know somebody experiencing homelessness, food insecurity or housing insecurity," she said. "You wouldn’t necessarily know it because they’re not going to talk about it, but it’s important to be kind and not judge what people are wearing or what they have."
For homeowners like Tatro, the rising costs of living has turned what once felt like a secure investment into a financial strain. When she and her husband bought their Milton home in 2022, they felt fortunate to secure a private sale through a friend in construction — avoiding the fierce bidding wars that had become the norm.
“We took a risk and agreed that my husband would commute for a while so we could find a home in the area,” Tatro said.
Now, just two years later, the financial reality has shifted. Property taxes have nearly doubled, and the couple is weighing whether to sell — estimating they could list their home for up to $570,000. But staying in Vermont has become increasingly difficult.
For renters, the situation is even more dire. Tatro’s daughter and fiancé both work full time, and spent months applying for apartments without success. Eventually they made the difficult decision to leave.
“They’re moving to Tennessee,” Tatro said. “It’s crazy. The cost of living here is just too high. We just can’t afford it anymore.”
Her story is one of many, where longtime Vermonters and newcomers alike are feeling squeezed out.
“It’s frustrating, especially when you’ve worked hard and invested in your home,” Tatro said. “If you’re looking to buy a house, you need to have some skills— whether it’s doing repairs yourself or having the right contacts to make things work.”
As the housing crisis continues, Tatro fears more families will be forced to make the same decision her daughter did— leaving Vermont in search of affordability elsewhere.
Experts agree that a multi-pronged approach is necessary to make housing more affordable. LaFond and Diamond both pointed to government policy changes as a key component, such as easing zoning restrictions and expanding programs for first-time homebuyers.
LaFond cited the state’s accessory dwelling unit (ADU) program as a step in the right direction for adding rental housing, but believes local zoning laws need further adjustments.
“I owned a duplex in Milton and wanted to add an ADU, but I was told I couldn’t because I already had a duplex,” she said. “Loosening some of these restrictions would be helpful.”
A study by the Vermont League of Cities and Towns found that nearly 70% of municipalities in the state have zoning regulations that limit the development of affordable housing. A change in these zoning laws could increase the availability of housing.
Diamond also suggested revising financing options for older homes.
“If we made it easier for people to buy and renovate homes, we could open up more options,” he said.
Nonprofit organizations and housing agencies are working to introduce more income-restricted housing options. The Champlain Housing Trust, which has developed affordable housing projects throughout Chittenden County, is exploring potential developments in Milton.
Meanwhile, the Vermont Housing and Conservation Board has increased funding for affordable housing projects, providing grants to incentivize new construction and rehabilitation of existing properties; and the Vermont Affordable Housing Coalition has called for an additional $50 million in state funding to support affordable housing development over the next two years.
"We need a multi-pronged approach that includes both policy changes and investment in new housing," LaFond said. "The demand is there, but without intervention, we’re going to see more families forced to leave Milton in search of affordability elsewhere."
As Milton and Chittenden County continue to grow, the challenge will be balancing development with affordability. Without meaningful action, more families may find themselves struggling to keep a roof over their heads— and the ripple effects will be felt throughout communities.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here