ESSEX TOWN — Amazon is in the midst of an application process for what would become its first-ever facility in Vermont. Their proposal?
To land the distribution facility, exceeding 100,000 units of square footage, in the Town of Essex.
The project has yet to obtain an official go-ahead, as the company and its engineering firm is in its site application phase currently. Proceeding under the name “Project Moose” and with little mention of the actual company’s name in the 55-page site plan application, the irony of the fauna-based project title and the namesake of Amazon itself is not lost on residents.
“You're paving Paradise,” said Aedan Koziupa of Montpelier.
The 23-acre site consists largely of woodlands and meadows in what is known to residents as Saxon Hill Forest. If the project moves forward, it would be replaced with impervious surface — fairly close to the Winooski River watershed and where events once deemed “100-year floods” have seemingly become annual, as a number of concerned citizens in attendance pointed out.
Still, Development Review Board members on Thursday were eager to reiterate many times throughout the meeting that the area in consideration for this project’s siting is zoned legally for industrial use — and the function of the meeting was a standard proceeding granted to any applicant.
An Amazon spokesperson, Steve Kelly, shared the same three-sentence statement with the Reporter as was provided to other Vermont-based news outlets.
“We appreciate the consideration of the Town of Essex as we explore the possibility,” he wrote. “Which would support providing fast delivery and great service to local customers.”
Town residents and neighboring Vermonters showed up and showed out Thursday, packing out the physical DRB meeting hall to capacity and with numerous attendees online, to raise questions, concerns and flat-out opposition.
Only the first participant’s question, regarding Amazon’s commitment to environmental sustainability and whether the company would operate in harmony with the surrounding forest, got a real-time response from Amazon representatives present — who reassured the concerned citizen that Amazon is the largest private purchaser of renewable energy in the world.
However, another participant chimed in later in the meeting to point out a flaw in the logic above.
“Saying that you're the largest [purchaser] of renewable energy isn't really saying much when you're the largest of everything,” said Winooski resident Drew Dean. “A bloated, beached whale is going to cast the biggest shadow on the beach, that's going to do nothing good for the environment surrounding it.”
At some points in the meeting, the anger in the room boiled over, with one resident telling a DRB member to “shut up” during his explanation of why the DRB’s consideration is standard protocol, followed by an apology coupled with continued opposition.
A different participant pointed out that sometimes it’s necessary to make considerations beyond just following traditional proceedings and to take morality into account in addition to the law.
“It's just another thing that's coming across your desk, but I don’t think that you should be waiving these buffers,” said Essex resident Elizabeth Dunbar, referencing environmental impacts to the nearby river.
“You should be listening to the public about what kind of businesses we do want to have, not only here in our town, but in our state,” she added.
Another attendee expressed concern that it appeared Amazon affiliates present at the meeting seemed to be chuckling at the statements of actual Vermonters in the room.
Other reasons for pushback from Essex Town residents and neighboring Vermonters were abundant. Some attendees posited that billionaires don’t care about the place they are coming to, and that the business cares far more about profit than people — referencing numerous stories in the news about the corporation’s business practices alleging union busting, and a lack of break allowances resulting in workers having to pee in jars, face injury or become disabled.
Not to mention, concerns about honesty and secrecy on the part of the large corporation. A few residents were shocked to hear of the plans at all, even those who are involved in the area. One Burlington resident alluded to the concept of “banality of evil,” advising neighbors to be wary.
Other concerns included noise, sound and environmental pollution, as well as concerns about dishonesty from Amazon spokespeople present, who say this would not result in substantially heightened traffic on Sand Hill Road, currently home to a family-friendly, walking neighborhood.
Although Amazon spokespeople and its contracted developers implied the area is not residential, several residents present who live on Sand Hill Road proved through their existence otherwise.
Attendees also questioned whether Amazon could possibly be a stable partner with whom to build, given the company’s track record of vacating large warehouses and distribution centers elsewhere as soon as uprooting becomes more convenient to the corporate bottom line.
Questions were also raised about whether proceeding with Amazon as a partner would go against Essex’s Town Plan entirely, which states the town’s economic development policies aim to maintain Essex’s rural areas while increasing and diversifying economic development, emphasizing startups, agricultural and home businesses and retail.
“I just don't see how [this could be done] in good conscience and in order to follow this goal of the town plan that was approved by the voters of Essex,” said resident Betsy McGavisk. “Supporting a business as large as Amazon has done so much to undercut home-based businesses and entrepreneurialism.”
“As well as their move to purchasing Whole Foods, their move to becoming a grocer,” she added. “Can you imagine what that's going to do to Vermont's farming economy?”
Attendee Katie DeSanto, who manages Phoenix Books in Essex, pointed out the arrival of Amazon in Vermont would threaten already-vulnerable small businesses, debilitate an already fragile publicly-funded mail service at the USPS, and crush local entrepreneurship at large.
She said Amazon and its founder, Jeff Bezos, have successfully devalued the book, but said that was only the beginning.
“Our toy stores, our hardware stores, our pharmacies — it supplies chain infrastructure that we actually already have in Vermont,” DeSanto said. “Bezos and Amazon have devalued our concept of time. Our patience, our delayed gratification.”
“Delayed gratification is so satisfying,” she added. “It's a lot like reading a book.”
DeSanto gives her USPS mailman Bruce Phoenix gift cards often, she said, and enjoys seeing his kids come shop at her store. With the introduction of a global, corporate, supplier behemoth that produces and delivers things fast by cutting corners where it hurts, she fears for the future.
Hinesburg-based attendee Tony St. Hilaire, principal officer of the Teamsters local 597, addressed Amazon directly on Thursday.
“I just want to welcome Amazon to this meeting,” he said. “We are not going to walk away from organizing your location if you come in.”
Williston resident Paul Cross, who’s been driving for UPS the last 20 years and himself is a union member through his Teamsters local, echoed St. Hilaire’s statement.
“I will be joining my fellow Teamsters in organizing Amazon workers,” he said.
Given the meeting wound up surpassing four hours in duration, the DRB’s members ultimately voted to end the meeting before all attendees wishing to participate had been heard, with the caveat that there will be future opportunities for everyone with a desire to engage to do so.
The same portion of this DRB meeting will be continued at a later date, with its May 1 meeting being the earliest possible option. The board intends to hold that meeting in a larger space than is typical. It is at that point that the Town expects Amazon to address the issues of concern.
“The DRB is tasked to review any application against the Zoning Regulations,” Essex community development director Katherine Sonnick told the Reporter. “In this case it is a site plan application.”
“It is always good to hear from residents and people from the surrounding communities, but the DRB is tasked to review any application against the zoning regulations,” she added. “The review is not based on who an applicant is, but if the use is allowed in zoning, if it complies with the zoning regulations’ site plan review criteria, and zoning district criteria.”
Sonnick reiterated that, per the legal zoning criteria, the site for the proposed facility is in the industrial portion of the Resource Preservation-Industrial District of the area. The RPD-I in Sazon Hill Forest is split into 40% industrial and 60% recreation/conservation.
The Amazon spokesperson, Steve Kelly, noted the process is in its early planning stages, with additional steps ahead, and said the company will share more when it is able.
But numerous residents made clear, at each and every step of the way, they will not back down.
“We’re all here for one reason: We know that the company is being run by the billionaires. This Brave Little State is really going to put up a fight, and I am going to love it,” said Essex resident David Skopin, followed by chuckles and cheers from the crowd. “They don’t give up.”
He then harkened back to earlier discussions of rainfall, and the impact of more deforestation and paving on Vermont’s habitats and overarching environment — implying that the results of such a move won’t be likely to spare its offenders.
“You're ready,” he said, directing his comments at Amazon. “But the Winooski has a different plan, and Mother Nature ain't backing down. Thanks for coming, because it's gonna be a show.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here