Onion City councilor sets sights on Montpelier; Thomas Renner looks to unseat Zuckerman in Democratic primary

Posted

WINOOSKI – Thomas Renner has spent most of his career as a political communicator.

But is the 34-year-old ready to unseat Vermont’s long-standing lieutenant governor, David Zuckerman, who has spent decades as a politician?

Renner is looking to give it a shot. 

As a gay Black man, he said he’s heard from a lot of Vermont progressives about the need to hear and amplify diverse, young voices. He looks at the state’s officials, however, and he doesn’t see the same message reflected back.

“Vermont is at this place where we are constantly talking about these values that we believe in, of empowering young people, of diversity,” Renner said. “I’ve been to so many meetings where we talked about trying to attract diverse people to move to Vermont, and as I looked at our statewide leadership, I didn't see anybody who was BIPOC, or many who were LGBTQ.” 

Renner was also involved behind-the-scenes during the Kitty Toll campaign, but Zuckerman beat the former challenger two years ago by winning the primary by a slim 4,500 votes statewide. This time, Renner figured he’d make an attempt as a candidate, continuing to point out the lack of change as part of a larger message to uplift underrepresented voices.

If he wins as lieutenant governor, he’s hoping to gather those viewpoints and present them to both state officials and legislatures to help inform the next round of lawmaking.

“It’s what I’ve done in my career,” he said. “I’ve had to have conversations and be in rooms that don’t always agree with me, or who I’m representing.” 

But first, he has to beat Zuckerman in the Democratic primary on Aug. 13.

Messaging as deputy mayor

“The lieutenant governor role is a messaging role,” Renner said last Tuesday from his backyard. “The message we want to send to Vermonters as well as those outside of Vermont is we are a state that embraces these democratic, progressive values and embraces young people’s opinions and diversity.”

Zuckerman doesn’t disagree with that idea. Listening to the two candidates side-by-side, they both use similar talking points, and they’ve both perused the Democratic playbook for policy ideas. Rather, Renner’s candidacy is closer to a call to action focused on  state officials who aren’t moving fast enough to tackle Vermont’s problems. 

For example, while many Vermonters agree there is an acute housing shortage, state actors often lack the necessary political will to make drastic changes. Renner said he knows what marginalized voices actually experience when such problems are allowed to fester. He argues that residents — especially those lower on the socioeconomic ladder — are now seeking out some sort of change as a result.

“I think a lot of folks are ready for something new,” he said. “I’m from a working class background. I bring a voice to those people. I know a lot of them, and they know what I’ve done and what I’ve worked for.”

Renner is looking to his lived experience to help highlight the differentiation. Renner categorizes himself as a gay Black man from a working class background, who is dealing with the challenges of being a young person in Vermont. Zuckerman, in direct comparison, lives in Hinesburg on a property few young people will ever be able to afford thanks to policy decisions made two decades ago.

As for his personal background, Renner said he moved to Vermont 17 years ago to attend UVM, and he ended up staying here, eventually landing in Winooski with his husband Michael to pursue a career in public communications. His latest gig was working for U.S. Rep. Becca Balint’s campaign, and he got started working in former senator Patrick Leahy’s office.

Renner didn’t become a political candidate, however, until last year. He ended up running for Winooski City Council earlier this year and got the job after getting voted into his first term. He also grabbed the position of Winooski’s deputy mayor — a quasi-ceremonial role similar to the lieutenant governorship.  

To emphasize his ability to listen to constituents, he highlighted his work this past budget season when Winooski had been considering a 14% tax increase. Renner said he helped advocate to lower the city’s tax rate down to 8%, thereby helping residents with their tax bills when the statewide school property tax rose roughly 14% in the same year.

Renner is also primarily a Democrat, compared to Zuckerman’s split ticket. The Progressive party signed up another candidate, Zoraya Hightower, to ensure Zuckerman could still be on the major ticket if Renner ends up winning as a Democrat.

Renner has received endorsements from Sen. Kesha Ram Hinsdale (D-Chittenden-Southeast), the first woman of color to serve in the state senate; former Rep. Kitty Toll (D-Caledonia-Washington); Sen. Brian Campion; as well as the Democratic-affiliated Burlington councilors.

“I’m somebody who’s very pragmatic,” Renner said. “I believe in working when everybody is involved and listening to every single voice. I understand what regular Vermonters are going through.”

Apples to onions

Despite their differing backgrounds, Renner and Zuckerman mostly agree on overarching policy.

Both express acute concerns about housing availability, affordability, the related impacts felt society-wide, as well as housing’s effects — most notably — on people’s lives. 

To solve the problems, both advocate for an approach to increasing housing stock by way of building dense, centralized developments, in a way that is conscious and considerate to the simultaneous preservation of natural environments.

Renner used Winooski’s growth as an example. While the center has been allowed to grow through looser regulations on housing development, Winooski’s outermost neighborhoods have mostly gone unchanged. In the same way, the state could help focus development on more centralized town centers, putting up a limited number of multi-unit developments throughout the state to better serve each population.

The two candidates proposed raising taxes on those earning over $500,000 to raise $75 million annually to provide funds needed to create permanent affordable housing. Despite the expensive nature of this work, Renner said the problem has grown too large to ignore as housing problems have created compounding issues throughout Vermont affecting just about every industry.

Renner said the problem has gotten to the point where Vermont even needs more high-end apartment complexes, as they help keep rental costs down thanks to more housing stock. Higher-tier housing availability will also likely serve to attract higher-earning workers crucial to Vermont’s infrastructure, like doctors, to the state. 

Similarly, the two blue candidates also see fairly eye-to-eye on climate change as a key priority, especially in light of recent flooding. Renner pushed for more weatherization, reducing or eliminating pesticides in personal gardens and state investments in an electric vehicle charging network. 

He emphasized Lake Champlain preservation as another example to look to in terms of why the environment is worthy of investment, as the lake sits at the intersection of environmentalism and economics. A healthier one could create more residency, recreation, tourism and business, he said. 

“We have this beautiful Lake Champlain that we feature in our marketing. People want to swim there, and then how many times are the beaches shut down?” he said.

Living diversely 

As the national debate around diversity continues to stir, Renner asked Zuckerman if he felt it was time to step aside for younger, more diverse voices. 

Zuckerman said he’s already made room, choosing to step aside when three women campaigned for the House of Representatives seat, despite him being well-suited for the job. 

He also argued that Renner doesn’t quite have the experience to fill in as governor, or be as effective leading the state Senate. While Renner wants more young voices in government, Zuckerman pointed out there’s a historic replacement of new blood in Vermont’s Senate.

Renner’s initial point about representation, however, still stands. This year, he’s the only candidate even challenging a government official on a statewide ticket. Few people expect him to win, and Zuckerman’s endorsements range far and wide after spending two decades in his role. 

“I can’t underscore how important representation is,” Renner said. 

To show an example, Renner said he celebrated with friends and family when he won his city council race in Winooski, and his nephew approached him during the party. 

“He said, ‘Uncle Thomas, I didn't think you would win, I didn't think that people like us could win,’” Renner said. 

Renner explained his nephew knew about President Barack Obama, and he recognized the discussions of diversity on the national level. But his nephew didn’t think a Black politician could win in overwhelmingly white Vermont.

“A big part of my messaging would be advocating for people from diverse and minority communities,” he said. “I bring a different voice, a different perspective… I champion workers' rights, but I do that because I am somebody who has directly benefited from workers’ rights. I’ve been in those situations… I deeply understand them and I think that voice is needed in Montpelier.” 

#minltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here