MILTON – During a packed Feb. 5 selectboard meeting, Milton town officials addressed errors discovered in the town’s annual reports spanning from 2013 to 2023.
The town report is a record of town activities in a given year. The errors were identified in this informational booklet, not Milton’s actual financial records.
“As we've outlined tonight, we've spent considerable time looking into our finances,” selectboard chair Darren Adams told the room of concerned residents. “I believe it was an excellent test of our system, and I believe that we passed that. I still don't like the idea that we could have had a faulty document out in public, but we did.”
“To be clear, there were errors, but the errors were not in our financial system and they were not in our financial records,” he added. “Rather, it was an inaccurate spreadsheet inserted in an annual report. There were no budget discrepancies. There is no money missing.”
The discrepancies were initially brought to the attention of town staff in December by selectboard candidate Lauren Blume, who found the errors during her personal review of the fiscal year 2022 municipal budget. The selectboard publicly thanked Blume for finding the mistakes.
“It was recently brought to the Town’s attention that there is conflicting financial information in the FY22 Annual Report,” the Town of Milton said in a statement Jan. 17. “After investigating, the Town found this to be a clerical error. On page 104, on the ‘General Fund Comparative Revenue and Expenditure Report,’ the numbers shown in the expenditures section of the column labeled ‘FY22 Actual’ are inaccurate.”
The FY23 Annual Report, currently in progress, will be updated to reflect the correct FY22 actual expenditures. The errors do not impact any of the calculations in the official financial reports reviewed by the auditors.
At the Monday night meeting, Jordan Plummer of Sullivan, Powers & Company, the auditing firm contracted by the Town of Milton, assured the public the town's finances from July 2022 to June 2023 were sound.
"An audit is not designed to find fraud. But, there are always a few fraud assessment motions we go through when doing an audit," Plummer said.
Town Treasurer John Gifford further outlined the internal controls in place to prevent fraud, highlighting that no single person could write a check or approve a purchase without proper authorization.
Gifford reassured the public there is no missing money and detailed the town's savings in various accounts.
"There is also no money from the town that is deposited into a non-town account," Gifford said.
Town Manager Don Turner asked third-party New England Municipal Resource Center to view the sheet independently and make their own assessment.
At the meeting, Willis "Chip" Stearns of NEMRC explained the errors were likely due to a reliance on external spreadsheets for data separate from the financial reporting system.
“So from my experience and after reviewing this, I just see that the reliance on external spreadsheets to provide data separate from, and not linked to, financial reporting can cause this type of situation on a regular basis. You're not alone suffering from these conditions," Stearns said.
“If you're taking a report that's printed out of the financial system, or from the auditor directly, and you're keying in values into a spreadsheet, once you've introduced someone between the seat and the keyboard the accuracy level goes down,” Stearns continued. “It is cellular driven… spreadsheets are highly suspect to user input having problems or by not maintaining it. A cell on the sheet could have been entered wrong…it’s simply user input.”
In a statement to the public, Turner assured residents the town had investigated the discrepancy, implemented new controls and conducted additional reviews for confirmation.
He urged residents with concerns to contact him directly, emphasizing transparency in addressing the issue.
“Thank you for explaining this. This presentation was very informative,” Milton resident Diane Barrows said.
Moving forward, the General Fund Comparative Revenue and Expenditure Report will be reviewed by the Finance Department, Town Treasurer and Town Manager.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here