Milton’s young artists use AP portfolios to tell their stories

Posted

MILTON — The morning bell rang at 8:45 a.m., and students trickled into the art wing at Milton High School, some balancing cups of coffee, others munching dry cereal as they found their seats.

Within minutes, the quiet hum of conversation gave way to the soft scratch of pencil on paper and the faint whir of a classroom fan drying painted canvases. AP Art students — Milton’s most advanced young artists — were already immersed in their work before the morning announcements had even finished.

Teacher Amanda DeCarlo, who has led the high school’s art program since 2013, moved between tables with the calm efficiency of someone who knows each student’s creative rhythm by heart.

AP Art is a college-level course, she explained. Students create a 15-piece portfolio, over the course of the year, about 12 or 13 finished works and a few experimental pieces showing the process.

“Each student starts with a question, and every piece they make is their way of answering it.” DeCarlo said.

Milton’s AP Art program began in DeCarlo’s second year of teaching, after she attended a weeklong “AP Camp” to learn how to guide students through advanced studio art instruction. This year, 14 students are enrolled — all working in 2D mediums, with four focusing on photography through the Milton Innovation Center.

The program is structured, but highly personal. Students select their own materials, mediums and guiding questions — an approach DeCarlo believes keeps them motivated.

“It’s not me saying, ‘You have to paint a sunset,’” she said. “They develop the question that drives their portfolio, and through that, they learn who they are as artists.”

Inside the portfolio

Senior Caitlyn Fortier’s guiding question is “What’s happening inside our brains?” — a theme she explores through bright colors, mixed media and humor. Her pieces often incorporate 3D materials, like sponges or mirrored tiles pulled from foam disco balls.

“I like touching things,” Fortier said, laughing as she pointed to a small disco-ball earring glued to one of her canvases. “It gives my art a trademark — people recognize it because it’s fun and a little weird.”

Her current piece, titled “Buying Brains,” features pastel-colored brains suspended in plastic, paired with the tongue-in-cheek slogan “Why learn when you can buy?”

“It’s about how people want shortcuts instead of putting in the work,” she said. “Like, why learn when you can just buy a new brain?”

Fortier said she chose AP Art partly to challenge herself and partly to end her senior year with something enjoyable. 

“It’s my escape,” she said. “It’s easy to lose track of time when you’re working on something you actually like.”

Nearby, senior Kelsi Chellis’ work delves into the five stages of grief, using emotional portraiture and raw texture to communicate pain and growth.

“I went through a horrible breakup last year,” she said. “I wanted to show that grief isn’t just about death — it can be about losing anything that mattered to you.”

Digital artist Karmen Dulmer takes a narrative approach. Her portfolio tells the story of a man searching for his missing best friend — a plot that came to her, she said, “in a dream.”

Her stylus tapped lightly on the screen as she showed her different pieces. 

“I’ve been drawing digitally forever,” she said. “But this class made me realize how much storytelling I can do with it.”

At another table, Wyatt Wright and Carter Luman shaded muscular, battle-ready warriors in pencil. Both said they’re drawn to fantasy imagery — and to keeping hand-drawn work alive in the age of artificial intelligence.

“You can tell the difference between AI-generated art and something made by hand,” Luman said. “Hand-drawn art has emotion. It needs to make a comeback.”

Art as reflection and identity

Not all portfolios are rooted in fiction or emotion. Some, like senior Bella Kang, bridge personal identity and cultural study.

Kang’s question — “How have animals been utilized through different cultures over time?” — grew out of her love for painting animals and a history-through-film class that sparked her interest in Indigenous storytelling.

“She’s combining her art with research,” DeCarlo said, gesturing toward two unfinished canvases side by side. “One reflects Indigenous perspectives, the other Western — both connected by how humans rely on animals. She’s using her work to talk about culture, symbolism and coexistence.”

Other students, DeCarlo said, are exploring memory. “We have a few portfolios inspired by childhood — self-portraits based on baby photos, or series that show them growing up. It’s deeply personal for a lot of them.”

Repairing more than murals

The class’ sense of ownership and expression extends beyond the studio walls.

Earlier this fall, Milton’s Black Lives Matter mural, painted by students on an electrical box outside the school, was vandalized. The response from DeCarlo’s students was immediate.

“It wasn’t even a question,” DeCarlo said. “They just said, ‘When can we go fix it?’ The only thing that stopped them was the rain.”

Working with tools from the Innovation Center, students designed new wooden stencils to make restoration easier if it happens again.

“We’re prepared now,” DeCarlo said. “Every time someone tries to ruin it, we’ll repaint it. It’ll always be there.”

She said the mural — originally created by students after the district voted to remove all flags except the American flag from school flagpoles — continues to symbolize student voice and expression.

“Student art is protected under free speech,” DeCarlo said. “And if our students want the mural, it’ll stay up. It’s their work, their statement — and they’re proud of it.”

Connecting creativity and community

DeCarlo sees that same pride reflected in her students’ day-to-day work. She said the program has evolved significantly since she started, particularly after AP submissions went digital following the pandemic.

“Before, we had to ship students’ physical portfolios — and sometimes pieces came back broken,” she said. “Now everything’s online, and it gives them more freedom to experiment.”

She also hopes to deepen community ties. Milton’s art department regularly collaborates with the Milton Artists’ Guild and local organizations like the Arrowhead Senior Center, where DeCarlo has hosted paint-and-sip events. This year, her students will again showcase their work during the school’s winter arts night in December.

“There’s a lot happening creatively in Milton,” she said. “Between the Innovation Center, the Artists’ Guild, and what’s happening here, it’s amazing how connected the art community is.”

Why art matters

Asked what she hopes students take from AP Art, DeCarlo didn’t hesitate.

“Perseverance,” she said. “You come up with your own concept, and you have the freedom to change it — but you still have to finish 12 or 13 pieces around one idea. It takes patience and dedication. That’s what they really learn.”

While few of her students plan to pursue art in college, DeCarlo said the lessons they gain reach far beyond the classroom.

“Art gives them a chance to fail safely and learn from it,” she said. “When something doesn’t go how they expect, they problem-solve, they adapt — and that’s life. It’s ownership. They make something that didn’t exist before them, and now it does, because of them. That’s powerful.”

As the morning bell rang again and new students filled the room, Fortier, Chellis, Dulmer and others kept working, lost in their creations — each piece an answer to their own question.

In a world of deadlines and data, the art room at Milton High remains what it’s always been: a place for curiosity, color and courage to take form.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here