Milton's flagpole dilemma: Students rally for inclusion, school board weighs options

Posted

In a packed Jan. 11 Milton Town School District school board meeting, students, teachers and community members voiced their opinions on the A41 Flagpole policy.

Unanimously, the board did not approve the policy, which would have created two flagpoles – one for the United States and Vermont flags, and one for flags representing student interests.

Board chair Kumulia Long responded to the vote by directing the Policy Committee to rework it, considering feedback from both the board and students.

Under revision to align with the Vermont School Boards Association's Model Policy Manual, the flagpole has become a focal point of discussion in the community since its first policy read on Oct. 19.

Back at the October meeting, Long had suggested rewriting the policy so only the United States and Vermont flags could fly, removing student interest flags from the pole and potentially moving them indoors. This, he proposed, could remove conflict within the community.

Board members Melinda Young and Karen Stout insisted on hearing from students before making a decision. A student-interest flagpole could be erected instead, they countered.

Currently, the policy asserts that district flagpoles are a form of government speech, under the control of the district, and mandates approval from the school board of trustees before flying any flag.

In 2019, after a two-year battle, the student activist group Milton for Social Justice won the right to fly the Black Lives Matter flag. Since then, it has flown on the flagpole in front of the high school. 

Prior to the Jan. 11 meeting, the school district conducted an online survey sent to student emails, and received responses from 140 students. Of those surveyed, 61 students, or 43.6%, voted against a Milton student interest flagpole. 

Among those speaking in support of the current policy was Milton High School senior Perrin Dulmer, representing 147 student peers who signed a petition favoring the flagpole policy.

“We started petitioning after the school board sent out their Google form, which we thought would capture the full breadth of students' perspectives, as well as human to human dialogue,” Dulmer said. “We, throughout this process, were able to engage in many conversations. This led to 35% of the student body signing this petition and showing support for the flagpole policy. 35% of the student body supported the policy which is larger than the historical average voting turnout of Milton, which is 20%.”

Dulmer urged the board to pass the policy, emphasizing its symbolic importance for unity and inclusion.

Contrasting views were presented by community member Mary-Anne Lynch, who argued for the inclusivity of the United States flag.

"We have a flag, the United States flag, that represents everybody in the country. No discrimination. That's all we need. We don't need anything else,” she said.

MHS faculty member Pete Wyndorf, adviser of Milton for Social Justice urged the board to support the policy, emphasizing its role in empowering students and sending a message of inclusion.

“We worked tirelessly to join schools across Vermont and across our nation to add the Black Lives Matter flag to our school flagpole,” Wyndorf said. “We listened to the criticism, we watched as it was twice stolen from our school grounds and twice when it was replaced. After three years of advocacy, we asked that in perpetuity, that until individual and institutional anti-Black racism ceases to exist, the flag should fly to signal our intention of continuing to work.” 

“This policy opens up the opportunity to install a dedicated student interest flagpole and a significant portion of the students and staff at MHS support the policy as you've written it,” he continued.

Community member Steven Nelson, however, advocated for a simpler approach, focusing solely on the United States and Vermont flags. Nelson expressed concern that additional flags could escalate divisions within the community.

“I think our pledge allegiance says it all: we can focus on one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. I think it incorporates all people,” Nelson said. “If we focused on that, which our Founding Fathers had put wise effort into, we don't need special flags. I think this new flag pole opens up Pandora's Box. “

“I think this is going way too far,” he continued. “I think you should focus on education. It's just going to accelerate the division of this school and of our community.”

During community comments, numerous members voiced support for chairman Long's original proposal. Community member Allison Duquette proposed that if those advocating for the flagpole were passionate about the cause, they should fundraise and handle logistics independently.

MHS alumni Cameron Laychak expressed disappointment at the potential removal of the BLM flag raised by students, arguing that it represented a symbol of inclusion according to the school website.

“I just like to say, first of all, this flag was raised by students,” Laychak said. “Students put the work in to get in front of this board and advocate for that flag. And now, it seems like all of you are going to try to take it away. It just doesn't make much sense to me.

“Second, that flag, on your own school website, says that it represents a symbol of inclusion, not anything more, not anything less,” Laychak continued. “So why tear it down? Especially if Milton wants to be this bastion of equity.”

Before the vote, Young questioned the cost of installing a student interest flagpole.

Matt Grasso, in response, disclosed an estimated cost of $4,500.

Young and the board expressed reluctance based on the expenditure.

"If it was a couple hundred or under $1,000, I'd say go for it and approve it,” Young said. “But, I can't approve something that is going to be $4,000-$5,000.”

As discussions continue, the Milton Town School District grapples with finding common ground amid diverse perspectives on the flagpole policy.

The Milton school board meets at 6 p.m. on the second and fourth Monday of each month in the Milton High School Library, located at 17 Rebecca Lander Drive.

Agendas and minutes are available at the Milton Town School District website www.mtsd-vt.org. For more information, call the District Office at 802-893-5302.

mtsd, milton town school district, milton school board, milton board of trustees, flag pole policy, united states, blm, melinda young, karen stout, kumulia long, milton flag pole, #minltop, milton high school, vermont

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here