Milton school budget revote: Tax increase drops to 2.9% ahead of May 19 vote

Posted

MILTON — Milton voters will return to the polls May 19 to decide on a revised fiscal year 2027 school budget which carries a significantly reduced tax impact compared with the proposal rejected on Town Meeting Day.

Since the March 3 vote, the projected education tax increase tied to the Milton Town School District’s spending plan has dropped from 9.8% to about 2.9%, according to district officials.

Superintendent Amy Rex said the change reflects a combination of local reductions and shifts at the state level, including adjustments to Vermont’s education funding formula.

“It’s a 70% decrease from the March 3 vote,” Rex said in a recent interview with the Independent.

The revised proposal follows voters’ narrow rejection of the district’s original $40.9 million budget, which failed by 26 votes.

What changed since March

District leaders say the lower tax impact is not the result of a single decision, but rather several factors.

On the local side, officials identified additional savings through staffing changes tied to turnover and new hires, adjustments to transportation routes and the elimination of a district-level communications position. 

Those reductions build on earlier cuts made before the March vote, which included the elimination of eight full-time positions, largely support staff such as supervisory aides and full-time substitutes, as well as one home-to-school bus route.

At the same time, changes at the state level — including an updated property yield and the use of education reserve funds — played a significant role in reducing the tax rate.

Without those state-level adjustments, Rex said achieving a similarly low tax increase through local cuts alone would have required far deeper reductions.

“Our initial budget … would have been a 0.057% tax increase without the CLA,” Rex said. “To get to that point with the CLA calculation, we would have had to cut about $2.5 million.”

For homeowners not eligible for income sensitivity, the revised budget is expected to translate to an increase of about $3 per month for a $100,000 home and about $15 per month for a $500,000 home.

Why deeper cuts weren’t made

Following the failed vote, the school board considered multiple reduction scenarios but ultimately chose the smallest option, which trimmed about $189,000 from the original proposal.

Rex said that decision reflected concerns about the cumulative effect of cuts already made in recent years.

“We’ve been making reductions every year,” she said. “It’s really at the point where the types of reductions we have to make have to change our program.”

District officials said additional cuts beyond those already approved would likely have affected student-facing services, including intervention supports, world language offerings, athletics and co-curricular programs. Further reductions could have extended into arts programming such as music and drama.

Even existing reductions are expected to have some impact in schools, particularly when staffing shortages require shifting personnel to cover classrooms.

“The reading specialist might come in to sub for a classroom teacher because you can’t function throughout the day without the staff you need,” Rex said.

What happens if the budget fails again

Under Vermont law, school districts must continue holding budget votes until a spending plan is approved. If Milton voters reject the budget again and the district enters the new fiscal year without an approved plan, officials say the consequences would be significant.

By July 1, the district would need to borrow up to 87% of its current budget to continue operating. That process would require paying interest and would limit available services.

“It’s time consuming, it’s costly, and you end up freezing all other kinds of services because you can’t pay your bills,” Rex said.

In that scenario, the district would be unable to fund transportation or athletics, leaving families responsible for getting students to school.

State formula driving local taxes

Rex and school board leaders have emphasized that local spending is only one factor in determining education tax rates.

The Common Level of Appraisal (CLA), which reflects the relationship between assessed property values and market sales, played a major role in driving the higher tax rate tied to the original proposal.

Rex said focusing solely on local school budgets can overlook how the state’s funding formula affects communities like Milton.

“This really is not about school spending for a town like Milton,” she said, noting the district is below the state average in per-pupil spending.

Message to voters

With the revote approaching, district officials are encouraging residents to review available information and participate in the process.

Rex described the upcoming vote as a reflection of community priorities.

“If you want reductions in certain areas, you have to be willing to accept the consequences,” she said.

Voting will take place Tuesday, May 19, from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. at the Milton Town Offices. More information about the proposed budget can be found at mtsd-vt.org. There will be a budget informational meeting at 6 p.m. this Thursday, May 7, in the Milton High School library, located at 17 Rebecca Lander Drive.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here