MILTON — In a pair of 3-2 votes Sept. 11, the Milton School Board adopted updates to Policy C28: Transgender and Gender Nonconforming Students and Policy A43: Board Conduct.
The decisions capped off a month of tension that began Aug. 14, when trustee Allison Duquette read aloud explicit passages from “This Book Is Gay” and trustee Scott O’Brien raised objections to transgender students’ participation in sports and privacy provisions. That meeting ended without a vote, and the board sent the policies back to committee.
On Sept. 11, the policies returned — and this time passed. Chair Karen Stout, Vice Chair Jeremy Metcalf and trustee Melinda Young voted yes. Duquette and O’Brien, who had introduced the motions to bring the policies to the floor, ultimately voted no.
The adopted version of C28 affirms that “all students are entitled to a safe and civil learning environment regardless of gender identity or expression.”
It directs staff to use a student’s asserted name and pronouns without requiring a court order, lays out procedures for protecting confidential records under FERPA and clarifies that transgender students cannot be required to use facilities that conflict with their gender identity. Privacy accommodations, such as single-stall restrooms or alternate changing spaces, will be made on a case-by-case basis.
In the days following the vote, the Milton Town School District Board of Trustees clarified that C28 has been in place since 2021 and was revised to remove outdated Title IX language and align with current state and federal law.
The statement from MTSD also noted that Vermont law has prohibited discrimination based on gender identity in schools and public accommodations since 2010, that single-stall privacy facilities have been available in Milton schools for more than a decade, and athletic eligibility for transgender students is governed by the Vermont Principals’ Association, not local boards.
Many residents, community members and school staff members spoke Sept. 11 to encourage the board to reaffirm the policy by voting “yes.”
“Transgender nonconforming students are not political by existing. They’re people,” Milton High School librarian Shannon Gile said to the board. “They don’t need to hear members of our board demean them and claim they have mental illnesses. … It is your job to protect all of them, and it’s my job to have their back.”
Resident Lindsey Lott called representation critical.
“When a student sees themselves reflected in a book, it helps them know that they belong,” she said.
Later, she spoke as a parent, saying she was grateful her child was able to disclose their identity on their own terms: “That choice was an act of trust, and it showed that the school put my child’s safety first.”
Several residents urged the board to ground decisions in law and best practice rather than personal views.
“Adopting these policies will help to change that injustice and keep your district in compliance with Vermont law and best practices,” Courage V. Pearson said, representing Outright Vermont, a statewide nonprofit that supports LGBTQ+ youth. “It will also go far to ending the lies that we are taught through misinformation and fear mongering. This is about all our children. This is not about ideology.”
Pearson also praised the district’s move as part of a broader state context: “The leadership in Vermont is a lighthouse in a storm across the country.”
Others stressed the stakes for students.
“For many of them, school is not just a place to learn math or reading,” district employee and parent Jamie Fletcher said. “It is the place where they discover who they are, where they look for acceptance, and where they decide whether their community believes they belong. If we fail them here, the consequences are lifelong.”
O’Brien reiterated his concerns before voting no, saying fairness in sports and parental involvement were at stake.
“I'm not against any transgender people. I'm not against any lesbians, gays, anybody out there. I'm trying to get it so parents are more included and involved, and our children, all of them, are protected,” O’Brien said. “With that policy, a biological boy can compete athletically against a biological girl, and I think that is unfair. I also don’t agree with a policy that gives permission to eliminate parents from the equation. … To eliminate them knowingly and keep it a secret is horrible, morally and ethically wrong.”
The section O’Brien referred to states transgender and gender nonconforming students may decide “when, with whom, and how much” of their identity information to share, and staff will respect requests to use a student’s chosen name and pronouns at school. That language is rooted in FERPA, the federal law that limits disclosure of student records without consent.
Some residents questioned the broader direction of the board. Longtime Milton resident Lynda Battistoni said meetings had become more about personal agendas than student well-being.
“If you’re going to start making policies, you need to use facts,” she said. “You need to check your agendas and your opinions at the door and come in and talk with respect about the kids that you’re all supposed to be working for. It’s been really disheartening, and I’m embarrassed, because people might forget that this is taped. Everybody can see this anytime, anywhere.”
In a separate 3-2 vote, the board adopted Policy A43, a new code of conduct outlining expectations for trustees and procedures for handling complaints or censures. The policy emphasizes confidentiality, limits individual authority, and sets standards for respectful engagement.
“This just covers the role of a board member… the tenets of good governance that every board member should be doing anyway,” Metcalf said.
Young said she welcomed clearer guidelines: “Everybody knows in this town I have a big mouth, and everybody knows that I say what I say. … I learned a lot my first year being on this board and how I can say it so I’m not offending other people. And I think with this board conduct policy that we have, everybody’s gonna learn it.”
O’Brien, who voted against the code, said he feared the policy could be misused to bully board members into certain opinions or behaviors.
“The code of conduct…I can see this being utilized to intimidate board members by community members,” he said. “If other board members want to try and intimidate other board members, I can see it being brought forward to do such. That’s why I stand there.”
Community members weighed in on the policy as well. Leroy Turner urged the board to reject A43, citing constitutional concerns over freedom of speech.
“I hope all of you will vote no on this code of conduct until it is rewritten to where it makes sense,” Turner said.
Not all speakers agreed. Krystina Gotsch supported adopting the code, saying it reflected expectations found on other public boards.
“If you’re on the board, you should be following such rules. Any other board has a code of conduct,” she said. “To say that you’re worried it’s going to take away free speech is kind of troubling. It makes me wonder what speech you want to give at a board meeting or to say to a teacher.”
While the policies are now on the books, the Sept. 11 meeting showed how deeply the issues resonate in Milton. Supporters framed the measures as overdue steps to protect vulnerable students and to align the district with Vermont law. Opponents raised questions about parental rights, fairness in athletics and free speech on the board.
“Our role as adults is not to shape [students’ identities] for them, but to ensure that they are safe while they do the important work,” Lott said to the board. “So I ask you, from one parent and a community member to another, please let your vote reflect care for our students, all of our students.”
To view the full Sept. 11 meeting and comments, go to LCATV.org/milton. Meeting minutes, official policy documents and more can be found at mtsd-vt.org.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here