Messages from Montpelier: Rep. Michaell Morgan offers his thoughts on education financing

Posted

April 16-19, 2024, Legislative Report

This past week in the House, the Ways and Means Committee passed out H.887, An act relating to homestead property tax yields, nonhomestead rates, and policy changes to education finance and taxation – simply known as the “Yield Bill.”  The bill passed on an 8-4 vote. Ways and Means is the committee of jurisdiction that can most affect education spending now. 

I attempt to make my reports as non-partisan as possible, but in this case, there was a clear philosophical difference between the Democrat and Republican members in the committee vote. The bill was crafted, debated, and had testimony on it for only 10 days. In the earlier drafts of the bill there were plans for near and long-term cost containment, which were part of the demands of Republicans on the Ways and Means Committee. However, the final draft of the bill saw most of these initiatives stripped out. Instead, we ended up with a bill that used two new taxes contained in it. These taxes are being utilized as an attempt at helping reduce the 200 million/20% tax hike projection that was highlighted last December 1st by Tax Commissioner Craig Bolio. The two taxes are in the form of a “cloud tax” on internet software and a short-term rental tax. They collectively raise approximately $27 million. Once again, we are saddling businesses with more tax burden.  This cannot continue. 

From a press conference held by Republicans on Thursday, Ways and Means member, Representative Scott Beck stated: “The Education Fund has grown from $1.5 billion to $2.3 billion in 10 years – It is now bigger than the General Fund of the State. It is the first time it has been bigger.”  He went on to quote Albert Einstein’s famous quote: “The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results.”  He went on to say that without the aforementioned provisions of cost containment (near and long term) that we are “simply left with insanity.”  He suggested that a combination of budget cuts and long-term reform are the answer. Let me be clear that I emphatically support our students, teachers and support staff who work tirelessly to educate our children in a tough environment. However, I think we can all agree that something needs to be done differently moving forward. 

In Governor Scott’s weekly press conference, he had the following words to say about where the House bill stands:

“Vermonters already face a daunting tax burden. Too many are struggling to get by, and simply cannot afford to see their costs continue to go up. Vermonters have also made themselves abundantly clear: taxes are crushing them. Months ago, when the December 1 property tax projection letter came out, my team warned about the consequences of such a historic tax increase. Unfortunately, many in the Legislature brushed it off and downplayed it. For years, I have voiced my concerns about the sustainability of our education system and have offered ideas for the Legislature to consider that would contain costs. They have rejected those ideas, time and time again – without following through on solutions of their own. Today, it is clear the House’s only plan is to accept an unbearable property tax increase, without any cost containment, while adding other taxes and studying the problem for a couple years. That means we will be in this same mess for years to come. I cannot accept this, I know Vermonters will not, and I hope the Senate does not either.”

I have advocated for change this session with my peers, but it appears this bill will likely pass on the House floor next week.  My hope is that we can possibly make some amendments for positive change to this bill or convince the Senate, when they get the bill to re-consider containing costs……… I hear from many people every week that Vermont is not affordable for them any longer. I will continue to fight for affordability in our state. 

As always, I can be reached at:  mmorgan@leg.state.vt.us or 802-881-7835.

Representative Michael Morgan

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here