Message from Montpelier: Senator Irene Wrenner explains her veto session votes

Posted

Message from Montpelier is a recurring column written by Essex’s legislative delegation. This message is from Senator Irene Wrenner (D-Chittenden North). 

After our 2024 session ended in May, legislators returned to the capital on June 17 for a veto override session. Gov. Phil Scott vetoed a significant number of bills this year.

Six were overridden. I will cover the headline makers below; a seventh, the veto on H.121, the Data Privacy bill, was not overridden. Consumer data is under constant threat, as is the well-being of children who use the internet. The bill addressed some of the addictive properties of children's apps. I voted to override, but the Senate fell six votes shy of doing so.

I wrote about H.687, the LAND USE bill, last month. I don't favor bills too complex to explain to constituents. No one's quite sure where all these new houses will be built, as every area has its constraints. One big constraint for certain towns is the handling of sewage, which is frequently and illegally dumped into our rivers and lakes. I believe we need to shore up this infrastructure before adding residents. Keep our waterways clean and our landscapes productive.

H.887, the YIELD bill sets the Homestead Tax Rate. It must be sufficient to meet the total amount voters approved in every town to fund their schools. The legislature, by law, must set a rate.

I've been asked why I didn't vote No on the override. Please keep in mind that the only way that several legislators can vote No on the Yield Bill is when a majority can be counted on to vote Yes, a politically fraught position because of the lack of understanding of what this bill does. I've spent the past week in conversation with residents who believe a No vote would've saved them money.

In fact, the veto of the yield bill itself appears to have been a risky political maneuver. The implications of not enacting the yield bill are serious: Vermonters would face property tax increases of up to 30% and there would be an $82 million deficit in the Education Fund, putting Vermonters and Vermont's public education system in an extremely tenuous position.

One important note: If you're on a fixed income or otherwise qualify for a discount on your taxes, you may be entitled to receive a homestead rebate. Up to 70% of Vermont property owners receive that discount, so not everyone would face the predicted 13.8% increase.

H.289, the RENEWABLE ENERGY STANDARD bill would add an estimated 2% to 7% to the cost of electricity in Vermont. (The total cost of this RES was estimated to be as high as $1 billion over ten years.) I believe this is an unaffordable means to an industrial end. Rather than levy a tax to accelerate the move to renewable sources of energy – not all of which are available when demand is highest – let's renew our focus on reducing consumption and conserving resources.

I recently learned that just 2% of greenhouse gas emissions in VT come from the generation of electricity. Maybe we should focus our efforts on reducing other, larger sources of carbon and methane emissions instead?

This article describes the underlying issue that I've come to see as the problem with bills such as last year's S.5 (CLEAN HEAT STANDARD) and this year's H.289, which were drafted by parties who stood to benefit: https://robertbryce.substack.com/p/environmentalism-in-america-is-dead.

Please know that I served for 15 years on the Essex Energy Committee. I am all about saving the planet through conservation, not consumerism.

H.72, OVERDOSE PREVENTION CENTER bill would provide a temporary, safe injection site in Burlington, to which people could bring and use illegal substances in a supervised environment and receive immediate attention if they overdose OR get help to stop using, if they so choose.

An OPC should free up first responders who were hired to fight fires and enforce the law, among other duties, but have been regularly called to deal with overdoses happening throughout the city.

I believe in local control. All the top officials in Burlington have begged for this pilot program. I voted to give them permission to try this, since they're low on options. Funding for this pilot comes from a drug company settlement, not taxes.

If we don't encourage substance users to remove themselves and their waste from Church Street, for example, I foresee the state losing tourist dollars. Vermont residents could then be asked to make up the deficit via taxes that no one is eager to pay.

Please send feedback to iwrenner@leg.state.vt.us. I post highlights from the State Senate and our district at www.facebook.com/SenatorIreneWrenner. Thank you!

#minltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here