This letter is from Karen Stout, chair of the Milton Town School District board of trustees.
The recent letter regarding the Milton Town School District Board meeting on December 4, 2025, contains several points that would benefit from clarification.
Policy C28 does not remove all restrictions from school sports or facilities, nor does it disregard student safety or privacy. The policy aligns with guidance from the Vermont Agency of Education and with current federal Title IX interpretations. It requires schools to consider age, developmental stage, safety, and competitive fairness, while also affirming that all students be treated with dignity and are free from discrimination or harassment.
The board also did not refuse to consider alternative language. It is important to understand how board policy is developed. Policy revision and adoption is a process that unfolds over time, beginning with Policy Committee meetings and continuing through multiple readings at regularly scheduled board meetings. During this process, the board considers public comment, written statements, and feedback from the broader community. Community input, including from students, was heard respectfully and weighed alongside legal obligations, student welfare, and the district’s responsibilities.
It is important to note, that after multiple readings and edits, the adoption of Policy C28, along with other policies that had been through the review process, was publicly warned for a vote as required by law. When a vote occurs, it does not prevent future review. Requests to revisit a policy are handled through procedures outlined in board policy, and that process is currently taking place for C28 specifically.
With respect to athletics, school sports in Vermont are governed by the Vermont Principals’ Association. Any application of local policy must align with VPA rules, which include considerations related to safety, eligibility, and competitive balance.
Finally, the Vermont School Boards Association has a structured approach to support local boards. The VSBA provides model policies developed with legal input to help districts remain compliant with state and federal law. It is an approach the District has always followed and as a result, it has served us well.
Reasonable people may disagree on complex issues, but those discussions are best served by accurate information and an understanding of how local governance works. The Milton School Board approached this matter thoughtfully and with the goal of serving all students.
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here