VERMONT – Accurate information is essential for Vermonters hoping to cast their ballots with confidence this November.
But mis- and disinformation on social media can cause confusion about the democratic process and manipulate people into acting a certain way or skipping the electoral process altogether.
Seán Sheahan, elections director for the Vermont Secretary of State’s office, said election mis- and disinformation can negatively impact Vermonters, but there are ways to deal with factually questionable content more responsibly.
While misinformation and disinformation may sound similar, their definitions refer to the two different types of motivation behind the content being produced.
Misinformation is information that is outdated or false, but not necessarily spread with the hope of deceiving. Disinformation, on the other hand, is always meant to mislead and is spread by malicious actors who are, in this case, hoping to disrupt the electoral process.
Sheahan thinks myths about the election do not just come from foreign actors, but from Vermonters who may lack awareness or education about how elections work.
“I think most Vermonters aren't looking to deceive other Vermonters, but they could misunderstand, or they could see disinformation and unwittingly spread that disinformation,” he said.
The Secretary of State’s office has a web page that dispels common myths about the democratic process on its website. For example, the site dispels the myth that mail-in ballots aren’t secure by explaining how those voting by mail must be registered to vote and pass multiple checks and balances from the Vermont electoral system.
Disinformation found on the internet sometimes uses deepfakes, content generated by artificial intelligence tools depicting real or non-existent people and events, to mislead potential voters about current events or even when their polling place is operational.
Voters should keep a look out for distinguishing features in AI images, audio or videos — like facial and body features that seem unrealistic or monotone speech. The Secretary of State’s office has a web page with more tips for identifying deepfakes on its website.
While local, state and federal law enforcement authorities and security experts are hard at work trying to mitigate the damage from mis- and disinformation, the average voter can also have a positive impact on this issue.
While disinformation is spread intentionally to cause harm, misinformation — even shared accidently — can still be dangerous.
One example Sheahan gave was a hypothetical social media post that says the polls are open a day later than they actually are. Sometimes this misinformation can be subtle but still have negative consequences on community engagement.
“If you lead people to believe they have more time to vote or election day is moved to a date later in November, even one day later, then you are undermining participatory democracy,” he said. “We'd all be worse off for that, because we'd have less participation in our democracy.”
Sheahan said that by learning to spot mis- and disinformation, whether it’s an elaborate deepfake video or a text-based post that seems too emotionally-charged to be true, Vermonters can protect themselves and their communities from being tricked.
“People should make an effort to consider the source,” he said. “If people see something that's coming from a questionable source or just posted online, go wherever the accurate source of that information would be.”
This could be the Secretary of State’s website, another State of Vermont website or a local city or town clerk, he said.
It’s also important to keep in mind how people’s political opinions are different from mis- and disinformation.
“If people can disagree over the best approach or best solution, but have a shared set of facts you're operating from, that’s based in opinion,” Sheahan said. “With mis- and disinformation, that's when it's not just an opinion, but it's outright incorrect.”
Comments
No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here