Community tensions rise as Milton School Board debates library and transgender policies

Posted

MILTON — Tensions ran high at Milton’s latest school board meeting, where board members and residents clashed over a high school library book, policies affecting transgender students and a formal complaint against a board member.

At the Aug. 14 meeting, the board reviewed revisions to existing Policy D8, which outlines how library materials are chosen and challenged. The updates spell out criteria such as educational value, age appropriateness and community standards. Ahead of the vote, a school board member gave community members a vibrant reading from one of the books in the high school library. 

Chairs shifted nervously, some shook their heads, and the occasional awkward cough echoed when board member Allison Duquette read a sexually-explicit passage from “This Book is Gay” aloud. 

The nonfiction guide by British author Juno Dawson is intended to educate LGBTQ+ youth about sexual health, identity and relationships. But for some board members and parents, its content crossed a line.

“This is about parental rights and what our kids have access to,” Duquette said, holding the book in her hands. “This book contains material that some families may find objectionable. We need to ensure parents are involved in their children’s education.”

Adding another layer of tension to the evening, the discussion over the book came alongside the board’s consideration of a formal complaint against trustee Duquette for an alleged conflict of interest. 

The complaint claimed Duquette may have represented her own special interest and has been influenced by political factors other than a fair presentation of all sides. Board members debated whether the claims rose to the level of an ethics violation or simply reflected policy disagreements.

These discussions also came against the backdrop of an email circulated among Milton educators prior to the meeting, encouraging teachers to attend and weigh-in on the agenda items. Some community members cited the email as an attempt to pressure or intimidate Duquette, while others defended it as legitimate organizing. 

Under the Milton School Board’s code of conduct, members are expected to avoid conflicts of interest and the appearance of conflicts, abstain from votes when such situations arise and disclose conflicts for the record.

When a motion to hold an informal hearing on the complaint ended in a 2-2 tie, with one abstention, the motion failed.

Duquette, a mother whose child is home-schooled, said the results of the meeting made her question sending him back into the public school environment.

“After seeing that and some of the comments made tonight, it makes me, as a mother and community member, really uncomfortable about sending my son back into the school,” she said. “If I were watching this from the outside, seeing how the union has targeted someone over policy disagreement, I would be very concerned about the school environment.”

The discussion over library materials intertwined with the first read of revisions to Policy C28, which is designed to guide support for transgender and gender nonconforming students. 

Board Chair Karen Stout explained that updates to the policy, which is taken from the Vermont School Boards Association, reflect legal reviews in response to new state laws. Key revisions included removing a Title IX reference and adjusting language regarding after-school activities.

“These are edits to reflect current legal guidance,” Stout said.

Duquette said her objections to the policy are not about transgender students’ identities but potential misuse of the policy and implications for the safety of female students.

Board member Scott O’Brien asked whether MTSD might be at risk of losing federal funding for having such a policy — given the stance of the Trump administration on transgender rights — but MTSD Superintendent Amy Rex said the district is currently in compliance with civil rights requirements. O’Brien said he is still concerned about potential legal challenges, but the board ultimately focused on revising the policy to reflect state law and Agency of Education guidance. 

He also questioned the policy’s impact on student access to athletic teams, though Stout noted sports participation is governed by the Vermont Principals’ Association, not the policy itself.

O’Brien remained blunt in his opposition. 

“Transgender girls competing against cisgender girls is not fair,” he said. “We have biological realities that matter. This policy could force our female athletes to compete at a disadvantage, and I am not willing to ignore that to appease activists or political pressure.”

He continued, warning of what he described as ideological overreach.

“This ideology isn’t everywhere. It’s a promotion of horrible, horrible stuff,” he said. “We have to ensure we’re balancing safety, privacy and legal responsibilities. Vermont law guides us, but parental notification and student privacy cannot be ignored.”

Not all attendees shared Duquette and O’Brien’s perspective. Stout repeatedly returned the discussion to students’ well-being.

“The children and the youth in our community must be the center of everything that we discuss,” she said. “Policies exist to protect them, and we need to make sure our actions reflect that.”

Under Vermont’s Fair Education Practices Act  and Agency of Education guidance, schools are required to protect students from discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity — including policies that prohibit disclosing a student’s LGBTQ status without their consent.

From the audience, voices rose in defense of inclusion and access. One resident argued that censoring books could cause real harm.

“These are kids who are growing into adults,” community member Lynda Battistoni said. “If they have questions and can’t go to somebody to talk to, they might get themselves in a worse situation by not having knowledge. We’re not talking about elementary kids — these are high school students, and they need access to information that can help them navigate who they are.”

Other speakers highlighted the potential consequences of denying access to supportive resources. 

“When a child tells me they are not safe to come out as who they really are in their home, I believe them,” Christine Vaughn, longtime educator said. “We should not put teachers in a position where they have to violate that trust, because if we violate it, it impacts every aspect of their learning — socially, academically, emotionally. For some students, the school may be the only safe place they have.”

Similarly, music teacher Jenna Schultz underscored the need for policies guiding support for transgender and gender-nonconforming students. 

“They exist, whether our policy does or not,” Schultz said. “We need guidance, recommendations and best practices to support them. What we care about is keeping our schools functional and safe for everyone.”

Ember Nova-Quinn, a transgender, nonbinary Milton resident and educator, spoke candidly to the board about the pressures LGBTQ+ communities are facing during today’s national climate.

“Adults don’t really get to learn something new unless they immerse themselves in it again and again,” Nova-Quinn said. “Every state in the U.S. now has laws targeting LGBTQ or transgender rights, except Vermont. Forty percent of this school board doesn’t recognize trans people. When you call trans girls boys or label us with mental illness, it sends a clear message to trans kids in our community. And they are here — they are students in every school.”

Paul Curtiss, who has worked in Milton schools for two decades, spoke in support of allowing students access to diverse perspectives. 

“There has never been a successful society that has banned books. Banning what students can access harms our community and our kids,” he said. “If we don’t let kids have access to this information, they’re going to get it somewhere else — uncurated, and often worse. We can do better for our students, and we should.”

Beyond public comments regarding C28 and library materials, several residents expressed frustration with the alleged conflict-of-interest claim against Duquette.

“We’re here trying to silence a sitting elected official,” Milton resident Shawn Tatro said. “This should never be coming up to this board. Allison has done nothing wrong, and this harassment needs to end. These teachers have continued to cost the taxpayers money and the school board important time with false accusations about elected board members…How can they sit here and constantly harass her? I am calling on the superintendent, who’s responsible for her staff, to resign.”

Jennifer Hoyt, another resident, tied the dispute to democratic representation.

“Silencing Allison undermines the democratic process and disrespects the voters who put her here,” Hoyt said. “When a board member is bullied or silenced for holding different views, it’s not just that member who is silenced — it’s every citizen who voted for them. Vermont law requires safe, civil school environments. Harassment or intimidation aimed at students, staff or board members has no place here.”

Thomas Hughes, a community member who defended Duquette, framed the situation as a difference of opinion rather than a conflict of interest. 

“There is no conflict here, only differences of opinion,” Huges said. “The current attack is just the latest iteration of an ongoing campaign against Allison. It’s vile and repugnant, and sadly, I don’t think it’s going to stop.”

C28, the policy addressing transgender and gender nonconforming students, is scheduled for a final vote on Sept. 11. The board voted to approve Policy D8 regarding the high school library. The motion passed with board members Jeremy Metcalf, Melinda Young and Karen Stout in favor, while O’Brien and Duquette voted against it.

Thursday’s meeting highlighted the local tensions that mirror national debates over LGBTQ+ rights, parental oversight and student safety. While some residents emphasized parental rights and transparency, others focused on protecting vulnerable students and providing access to supportive resources. 

Both sides agreed on the importance of community engagement, though they differed sharply on what that looks like in practice.

As Milton schools prepare for the upcoming academic year, these discussions will continue. Library materials, transgender student policies and board governance will remain closely watched, reflecting broader national conversations about education, diversity and the role of local school boards in shaping learning environments.

While disagreements are inevitable, the conversation about inclusivity, safety and community values will continue to shape the Milton school system in the months and years ahead.

To watch the full 2.5 hour long meeting, visit LCATV.org/milton or MTSD-vt.org.

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here