Child care bill sparks debate over access, quality

Posted

VERMONT — Inside Spark Academy on a recent morning, backpacks hung from cubbies labeled with children’s names, scrambled eggs were served for breakfast and small hands tugged at sleeves as teachers helped children get ready for the day.

One child cried after learning rain would keep the class from going outside. A teacher knelt beside her, held her close and helped her settle back into the rhythm of the classroom.

For Vickie Gratton, co-owner of Spark Academy in Swanton, those moments show why early childhood education is more than watching children while their parents work.

“You’re teaching them how to be a little human,” Gratton said. “There are so many facets to making a healthy child.”

A bill currently moving through the Vermont Legislature would reshape how the state recognizes and regulates that work. S.206, known by supporters as the Early Childhood Educator Profession Bill, would create a new individual licensing system for many early childhood educators working in child care programs regulated by the state’s Child Development Division.

Supporters say the bill is the next step after Vermont’s major child care investment under Act 76, which expanded financial assistance for families and helped stabilize child care programs. They argue S.206 would create clearer career pathways, improve training and give early childhood educators the professional recognition they have long lacked.

But some providers and local officials worry the bill could also make an already difficult system harder to navigate, especially in communities where child care slots are limited and providers are struggling to hire.

For local families, the debate lands in familiar territory: child care is already difficult to find, expensive to keep and essential for parents trying to work.

“Childcare remains a huge and critical need in Milton and in most Vermont communities,” Benjamin Gilbert, community outreach manager at the Milton Family Community Center, said. “Families are having difficulty finding available child care slots, and those who have secured spots designate a large portion of their income to keep those spots.”

Details and concerns

Under S.206, Vermont would create a Board of Early Childhood Educators within the Office of Professional Regulation. The bill outlines several license types, including Early Childhood Educator I, II and III, as well as a family child care provider license.

An Early Childhood Educator I license, generally intended for assistant educators, would require a high school diploma or equivalent, field experience and completion of an approved credential program with at least 120 hours of training and instruction. An Early Childhood Educator II license, generally tied to lead educator roles, would require an associate degree in early childhood education or a related field, or an associate degree in another field with 21 approved credits in core early childhood education competency areas.

An Early Childhood Educator III license would require a bachelor’s degree in early childhood education or a related field, or a bachelor’s degree in another field with 21 approved credits in core early childhood education areas.

The bill includes transition periods for some current educators and providers, and the major licensing requirements would not take effect until July 1, 2028. Some transitional licenses could continue for several years, with parts of that transition extending until 2036.

The bill also sets license fees, ranging from $125 to $225 for initial applications and $225 to $275 for biennial renewals, depending on the license type. The Joint Fiscal Office says the bill would appropriate $262,000 from the General Fund in fiscal year 2027 to the Office of Professional Regulation and create two new positions to begin implementation. 

The licensing system is estimated to generate about $792,500 in initial license fee revenue in fiscal year 2029 and about $1.2 million in biennial renewal revenue in future odd-numbered fiscal years.

The program will bring new, needed revenue to the state, but the cost structure is part of what has raised concern among some lawmakers and providers.

Gilbert said MFCC supports safe, high-quality child care, but worries that new requirements could create another barrier in a system that is already under pressure.

“S.206 would likely create a higher barrier for accessing childcare in our community,” Gilbert said. “Childcares are already competing to attract, hire and retain staff from the limited pool of qualified childcare workers that exists, and the increase in licensing requirements would exacerbate those challenges.”

Gilbert said staffing shortages can lead to classroom or program closures, which in turn can have immediate consequences for families.

“Not every family has built-in backup caregivers who can cover in the event of an emergency closure, which can lead to lost wages and work for parents,” he said.

Families unable to access child care often face a chain reaction: less income, less flexibility and a greater need for food access, financial assistance or other support programs.

“Changes at the state level will absolutely impact Milton families,” Gilbert said. “Families could expect less child care availability in general, and at higher costs.”

Sharron Harrington, executive director of the Vermont Association for the Education of Young Children, said those concerns are real, but she does not see S.206 as a mechanism for raising costs.

“This bill is not intended to increase the cost for families,” Harrington said.

Recognition and respect 

Act 76 “fundamentally changed and stabilized the financial picture for child care,” Harrington said, and S.206 is intended to strengthen the workforce behind that system.

“The biggest barrier right now for Act 76’s success in the child care industry itself is staffing,” Harrington said. “S.206 is the next step.”

She said the bill grew out of years of work by early childhood educators across Vermont who wanted a clearer, unified profession with more recognition and respect.

“What S.206 will do is create a clear statewide framework for what it means to be an early childhood educator,” Harrington said. “The status quo isn’t working, and they know that.”

Harrington said the bill is designed to build a stronger profession, not push people out of the field. She said transition periods and existing scholarship programs are meant to give current educators time and support to meet new requirements.

“This is the long game,” Harrington said. “This is changing the trends and the trajectory of an under-resourced and undervalued profession to something that will be a desirable career choice.”

The question of recognition is personal for Laura Butler, a Milton resident who operated Imagination Island, a family child care program from her home, for more than 30 years before retiring in 2025.

Butler opened her program in 1991 after leaving another professional job. Within months, she said, she realized how isolated family child care work could be.

“People really thought of me as a babysitter, and I wasn’t a babysitter,” Butler said. “I had left a professional job to do this service in my community.”

Unlike larger centers, family child care providers often work alone. Butler said she was the nurse, the lunch provider, the caretaker and the person parents turned to with concerns. But she said support was limited, especially when meetings or trainings were scheduled during the day, when providers were feeding children, putting them down for naps or running their programs.

“In a center, you have seven or eight employees,” Butler said. “In a home, you’re doing everything.”

Butler eventually became involved with the National Association for Family Child Care, earned accreditation and helped create a local provider network where family child care providers could meet, share training and talk through problems.

She later served on the task force which helped shape the recommendations behind S.206. Butler said her priority was making sure family child care remained viable.

“My goal was to make sure that nothing was put into a policy or a law that would shut down family child care,” Butler said.

She was initially cautious about increasing education requirements, especially because she knew experienced providers who did not have formal degrees. But she said the final structure includes enough flexibility and transition time for existing providers.

“I’m not saying you have to go to college to care for children,” Butler said. “But what I’m saying is you need to have some type of formal education. These aren’t your kids. You are educating and caring for someone else’s children.”

Butler earned an associate degree, bachelor’s degree and master’s degree during her career, using available support to pay off her education debt before retiring. She said that education changed how she viewed her work, especially when caring for children with developmental delays, disabilities or other needs.

Although she is retired and would not personally benefit from the bill, Butler said she supports it because future providers and children may benefit.

“There’s a whole new generation that is going to benefit from this,” Butler said. “Children being born now and going into programs now are going to be better cared for because they’re going to have a better-suited educator.”

Room for improvement

In Swanton, Gratton’s path illustrates what supporters say the bill is trying to make more visible.

She began as a stay-at-home mother caring for a neighbor’s child. She later became a registered home provider, joined the food program and pursued more training. Through assessment of prior learning and college coursework, she earned her associate degree, then her bachelor’s degree.

In July 2024, Gratton and her business partner opened Spark Academy in Swanton. Six months later, they opened Baby Spark, an infant and toddler center. Between the two programs, Gratton said they now serve about 54 children.

“We opened Baby Spark because there was such a high need of zero to 3,” she said.

Gratton said opening a center gave families more flexibility than a home-based program could provide, including longer hours and more staffing coverage. It also created jobs and allowed staff to have paid time off, something which can be difficult in home-based care where one provider may be responsible for all families every day.

Still, she said the work remains hard. Spark Academy deals with staff turnover, which Gratton said is partly due to people entering the field without fully understanding it.

Gratton said she supports S.206 overall because she believes it will help professionalize the field and give new workers a clearer pathway. But she also acknowledges concerns, especially for longtime home-based providers nearing the end of their careers.

“As someone who was a home provider who didn’t have a degree, I would be a little frustrated that I’d have to get on that wagon, especially if I was at the end of my career,” Gratton said.

She also said lawmakers should look closely at costs, including whether providers would end up paying for overlapping licenses or duplicative requirements.

Gilbert said he would like to see increased licensing requirements paired with more support for the industry, including training programs, professional development opportunities and expanded financial assistance for families.

“Our children deserve the best care possible, and the child care centers committed to offering top-quality services need more support and resources to provide consistent and sustainable care,” Gilbert said. “It’s in everyone’s best interest to build a child care system that is safe, well-supported by the community and affordable.”

That is the goal, according to Harrington. She said S.206 is not about overregulation, but about accountability, transparency and respect for a workforce that cares for children during some of the most important years of development.

“For families, this means more stability and more transparency for who’s caring for your child,” Harrington said.

S.206 passed out of the Vermont Senate in late March and is now being reviewed by the House Committee on Human Services. 

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here