Banned Book Tour sparks dialogue on free speech and inclusion at Milton High School

Posted

On Tuesday night in the Milton High School library, Lt. Governor David Zuckerman’s Banned Book Tour illuminated the profound influence words can wield. 

From 5-6 p.m. on Dec. 19, about 30 community members gathered in the MHS library to explore the potency of narratives that had previously tiptoed on the edges of societal acceptance. 

Sponsored and co-hosted by the Milton Inclusion and Diversity Initiative, the event aimed to foster conversations about free speech, inclusion, democracy and open dialogue.

Throughout this year, Lt. Gov. Zuckerman has traversed the state, engaging in book readings from banned books at various Vermont bookstores and libraries. 

The Milton stop featured four community members reading from banned books, including "Gender Queer" by Maia Kobabe, "To Kill a Mockingbird" by Harper Lee, "The Bluest Eye" by Toni Morrison and "This Book is Gay" by Juno Dawson.

Ember Nova Quinn, a resident of Milton, opened the readings with a selection from "Gender Queer." Nova Quinn, a transgender non-binary individual, emphasized the lack of representation and understanding during their formative years.

“I grew up in the 1970s and 80s, and there wasn't anything about transgender people. All the books about sex in our library were on the top shelf, and we had to ask the librarian to get them down. It was hard because you don't hear anything in the movies or on television. It was all very derogatory in LA, laughable against trans people," Nova Quinn said.

Nova Quinn emphasized that having access to information through books is important, especially for someone who is figuring out their own identity.

Grant Rees followed with a reading from "To Kill a Mockingbird," expressing admiration for the protagonist, Atticus Finch, who inspired him to become a lawyer. Rees acknowledged the discomfort some feel with the book's themes of racism, but highlighted Finch's message of seeing people for who they are.

Gabby Lavee, a senior at MHS, read from "The Bluest Eye," emphasizing the societal standards imposed on individuals and the book's message that one doesn't need to conform to be amazing.

Dev Welch rounded out the readings with a passage from "This Book is Gay," underscoring its role as a resource for queer individuals navigating their identities.

“However thick our skin is, I imagine even the toughest young LGBTQ+  person has thought, ‘Oh, this isn't going to be easy’, and it isn't. It's never going to be for us,” Welch said. “Although we may be pleased we figured ourselves out and some of us may have the most supportive parents or caretakers in the universe, we all know that we're coming out into a world that is littered with faithfulness. But it's adversary that makes LGBTQ+ people strong. It's why we call ourselves proud.” 

After the readings, Lt. Gov. Zuckerman facilitated an open discussion about banned books, addressing questions and concerns from attendees. One community member questioned the role of elected officials in book selection, to which Zuckerman responded by advocating for the expertise of librarians and teachers in making those decisions.

“What is decided in our libraries is not something that should be a universal decision by a governing body, who are not trained or educated in the academic side of schools or classrooms,” he said. “Those professionals, librarians and teachers, have been making those decisions for decades and centuries. But, parents in Vermont always have the right to say ‘No, I don't want my child reading this book’.” 

While Vermont currently has no banned books, the trend of book challenges is on the rise nationwide. According to data from the American Library Association covering the first eight months of 2023, there have been 695 challenges to library materials and services, representing a 2.2% increase from the same period in the previous year.

“There have been people in our state that have run for school board in various communities who have discussed the topic of trying to restrict access to books in the school systems that they're running for school board in. That's one of the reasons I thought it was good to have these conversations, so we could have a deeper understanding of what the broader topic of book banning has done in other societies in the past," Zuckerman said.

The evening's discussions delved into the historical context of marginalized communities and the evolving societal perspectives that have allowed for greater acceptance. Attendees explored the challenges of addressing controversial topics in a small community setting.

“Even though Milton is a small, close-knit community, we don't have opportunities to come together in the community like this very often. When it's something that is maybe controversial or difficult, we tend to not want to get involved. What we need to do is have more of these opportunities so we actually can continue to have dialogues like tonight. Nobody yelled, nobody raised their voice and we got to see both sides of the issue,” organizer of the Milton Inclusion and Diversity Initiative Lisa Rees said.

The event at Milton High School aimed to emphasize the importance of preserving access to diverse materials and to address the potential repercussions associated with book bans. As the evening concluded, organizers expressed hope that the dialogue would pave the way for future discussions on broader issues of racial equity, social justice and inclusion within the Milton community.

“Starting in January, I'm going to be putting out feelers to the community about getting an informal group to come together to talk about racial equity, social justice, inclusion and belonging in Milton. My goal for 2024 is, instead of focusing on the politics of these issues, how do we show together that we live our values? That's what I'm hoping and that this event will have planted some of those seeds,” Rees said.

Those who would like to learn more and get involved with the Milton Inclusion and Diversity Initiative can follow MIDI on Facebook at https://www.facebook.com/midivt. 

banned books, banned book tour, lt. governor david zuckerman, ember nova quinn, to kill a mockingbird, this book is gay, gender queer, the bluest eye, grant rees, dev welch, gabby lavee, lisa rees, milton vermont, milton high school, libraries in vermont, #minltop

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here